2008 News Archives
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
2007 News Archives
October 2008
Granholm Signs New Energy Policy
(Gongwer News Service, October 6, 2008)
Governor Jennifer Granholm said the state would see new jobs with her signature on legislation requiring Michigan utilities to use more renewable energy. And environmental groups said the state's overall health would improve. But competitors challenged supporters to show over time that the restrictions on choice under the new legislation still kept rates down.
Under the new laws (HB 5524 , PA 286; SB 213 , PA 295; SB 1048 , PA 287), utilities would have to use at least 10 percent renewable power by 2015. They also have to help customers cut at least 5.5 percent of their potential power demand through energy efficiency programs over that same period. And customers would receive tax credits for purchasing certain energy efficient products. But the bills cap customer choice at 10 percent of the load for Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison to give them the demand stability they said they needed to be able to finance new power plants in the state. (full article)
Michigan’s energy regulations now law
(Crain's Detroit Business, October 6, 2008)
Michigan’s newly passed energy regulations have become law, with Gov. Jennifer Granholm signing the measures on Monday.
Included in the three-bill package are provisions that alter utility rate structures and rate approvals, require utilities to obtain 10 percent of their electricity from renewable sources by 2015, and set limits of 10 percent on the amount of a utility’s customer load that can go to alternate suppliers.
The Customer Choice Coalition, a group that fought against the restrictions on electric choice and some other provisions, called on lawmakers to monitor the impact of the new laws. (full article)
Granholm signs Mich. energy package into law
(Associated Press, October 6, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm on Monday signed into law a package that will require more electricity to come from renewable sources, raise residential rates, restrict competition among power companies and encourage energy efficiency.
Granholm held two energy bill-signing ceremonies, one in Detroit and one in Eaton Rapids southwest of Lansing. She said the new measures will create new renewable energy jobs.
Workers at Dowding Industries in Eaton Rapids looked on from the balcony of a new manufacturing plant as she signed the bills. Dowding President Jeff Metts said the factory is poised to build components for wind turbines once orders come in. He said he's already heard from three companies in the two-and-a-half weeks since lawmakers passed the package. (full article)
Gov Beams Energy At Bill Signing
(MIRS, October 6, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM signed today a three-bill alternative energy package, which she heralded as having "the greatest potential to transform the state" of any piece of legislation she had signed in her six years as chief executive.
During a pair of public signings in Detroit and Eaton Rapids, the Governor focused almost entirely on the job-creating potential of the alternative energy aspect of the broad-sweeping legislation. The new law requires that 10 percent of the state's energy come from renewable sources by 2015, a number that alternative energy experts acknowledge could be reached today with some investment in wind energy. (full article)
CCC urges lawmakers to watch carefully impact of new monopoly-driven energy policy on rates, development of renewable power - CCC Press Release
(October 6, 2008)
As Gov. Granholm signed into law the state’s new energy policy putting control of the state’s electricity future in the hands of two monopoly utilities, the Customer Choice Coalition asked lawmakers to carefully monitor the impact of the law.
“We still believe competition and markets work better than monopolies and government regulators. It is now incumbent on supporters of this policy to prove to Michigan that regulation can work better than competition to hold down rates while increasing energy generation in the state,” said Barry Cargill, executive director of the Customer Choice Coalition. (full press release)
State drops ball on energy
(Lansing State Journal, October 13, 2008)
The LSJ's Sept. 28 editorial orrectly notes that the Legislature approved a "bailout" plan for the state's two largest utilities, despite the fact that "Consumers Energy and DTE, are experiencing substantial profits."
This occurred despite the fact that the utilities were "bailed out" in 2000 by the Legislature in return for opening their systems to competition. (full article)
September 2008
Mich. residents may pay extra for green power
(Associated Press, September 1, 2008)
Saying it's only fair, Michigan lawmakers plan to raise residential electricity bills and drop business rates so all customers are charged the true cost of their power.
But when it comes to figuring out who should pay what for new renewable energy requirements, the playing field wouldn't be even.
Though residents account for one-third of Detroit Edison's electric sales, they would contribute two-thirds of what Michigan's largest utility could collect from customers for wind and other sources of alternative power under bills that have passed the House and Senate. (full article)
Legislators must let the public in on energy debate
(Oakland Press, September 3, 2008)
The Michigan Legislature has had before it for some time a wide range of bills to rewrite electric policy in Michigan. Some of the legislation is strongly supported by environmental groups. The bills call for heavy investment in what is considered "green sources of energy -- wind, water, etc. The goal is to make the state more energy efficient and eventually to free it from its dependence on oil, natural gas and coal -- the carbonbased sources of fuel.
Other proposed bills, generally backed by Michigan's two largest utility companies -- DTE Energy and Consumers Power -- call for construction of nuclear and coal-fueled energy plants. These bill are vehemently opposed by environmentalists, who don't like the dependence on the carbon fuels. (full article)
Vote on Energy May Not Happen This Week
(Gongwer News Service, September 8, 2008)
Governor Jennifer Granholm is urging the Legislature to complete work on a utility regulation reform/renewable energy package in this first week back to session since the summer recess, but officials indicate a final vote may come later in the month.
There is a chance of an agreement between the House and Senate on legislation to set a renewal portfolio standards, SB 213*, officials said, but it could go into the second or third week of the Legislature's three-week September schedule before a decision is reached on HB 5524*, the legislation that would deal with utility regulation. (full article)
House Dems Want Energy . . . So Does GOP
(MIRS, September 8, 2008)
Lawmakers are returning to Lansing Tuesday and bringing with them their optimism that a deal can be struck this week on the energy package that has languished in the House and Senate since last year.
And while the chances of a conference committee report on either HB 4524 or SB 0213 are still 50/50, a unique dynamic is developing in the House. Both Democrats and Republicans are crossing their fingers a vote on either bill is taken within the next three weeks. They want the ammunition in the November election.
Democrats believe the package is a political plus. Republicans believe the package can be framed as a de facto electric bill increase and use as a political hammer against politically vulnerable Democratic incumbents. (full article)
State energy bill will hit consumers hard
(The Detroit News, September 10, 2008)
Michigan has no hope of returning to economic growth if it chokes off its energy supplies or makes electricity prohibitively expensive. That truth should guide lawmakers this week as they struggle to reach a compromise on a comprehensive energy plan for the state.
Gov. Jennifer Granholm and House Democrats are asking for an energy bill that, among other things, would mandate 10 percent of the state's electricity come from renewable sources -- wind, water, biofuels, etc. -- by 2015 along with a 5.5 percent requirement for reducing overall energy use. (full article)
Legislators working to finish energy-reform bills
(Crain's Detroit Business, September 12, 2008)
Lawmakers are closing in on Michigan energy reforms.
Negotiations were continuing Friday and at least one Tuesday conference committee meeting is scheduled, as lawmakers look to put their final seal on legislation that would boost Michigan’s use of renewable energy, limit customers’ ability to choose alternative electricity suppliers, alter utility rate structures and establish a new approval process for power plants and utility rates.
The impending finish comes amid urging by DTE Energy Co., CMS Energy Corp., major business associations and others in the Michigan Jobs and Energy Coalition. (full article)
Energy Bills Finally Completed, Head to Governor
(Gongwer News Service, September 18, 2008)
More than one year's effort to enact major changes to the state's utility regulation system and to establish a renewable portfolio standard for the development of alternative energy sources finally reached completion Thursday as the Legislature approved compromises on HB 5524 and SB 213.
The conference reports on HB 5524 were approved on votes of 78 to 29 in the House and 25-11 in the Senate, and on SB 213 on a vote of 26 to 10 in the Senate and in the House on a vote of 83 to 24.
Also approved was SB 1048 , which grants an income tax credit to consumers who purchase Energy Star rated appliances, the most efficient now on the market. (full article)
Granholm will sign bills to raise power rates, increase alternative energy
(Detroit News, September 18, 2008)
An energy package that will raise residential electric rates by up to 12 percent, require more electricity to be generated by renewable sources and put a cap on competition to the major utilities won final passage in the Legislature Thursday.
Gov. Jennifer Granholm, who has been pushing for expansion of renewable energy for months, will sign the two bills in the long-awaited energy plan "as soon as they reach her desk," spokeswoman Liz Boyd said.
The legislation calls for 10 percent of Michigan's electric power to come from renewable sources such as wind, solar and hydroelectric power by 2015. Currently, about 3 percent of the state's electricity is generated by these sources. (full article)
Energy Passes At Last
(MIRS, September 18, 2008)
After months of being "90 percent there," the alternative energy package that kept most of the Lansing lobbyist corps gainfully employed since last fall finally passed the Legislature today.
Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM, who had long championed the package and led a town hall on energy at the Democratic National Convention, was already touting it on her trade mission in Japan. She and Democrats claim it will create 30,000 new jobs, although Senate Majority Leader Mike BISHOP (R-Rochester), who ultimately supported it, was skeptical. (full article)
Reaction Mixed To Compromise
(MIRS, September 18, 2008)
Reaction around Lansing to the soon-to-be signed energy package ranged from exaltation to dismiss with consumer groups and competitive energy suppliers making up most of the latter category.
With the state's competitive energy market now limited to 10 percent of the market, DTE Energy and Consumers Energy will be able to swing a bigger bat, which the alternative energy suppliers say will mean more money coming out of the consumers' pockets. (full article)
Michigan lawmakers approve sweeping energy plan
(Associated Press, September 18, 2008)
Lawmakers on Thursday approved a plan that requires more electricity to come from renewable sources, raises residential rates, restricts competition among power companies and aims to make homes and businesses more energy-efficient.
The result: Residential electric bills will go up by 8 percent to 20 percent over five years -- but not by as much if the Legislature had done nothing, according to backers who said Michigan now is assured of reliable, cleaner power and not needing to build as many coal-fired plants.
House Energy and Technology Chairman Frank Accavitti said the three-bill package will be "a wash" for customers if they take advantage of new energy-efficiency programs. They might get rebates to buy compact fluorescent light bulbs and efficient appliances. Home energy audits could be re-instituted. (full article)
Wind and sun to help out, in time
(Detroit Free Press, September 19, 2008)
New requirements for electric utilities to produce more power from renewable sources won't add more wind or solar power overnight, but the legislation is a step toward a more renewable energy future and should help homeowners with wind turbines or solar panels.
The requirement that companies bring in 10% of their power from renewable sources by 2015 won't really add much to the state's electric grid for several years. (full article)
State's electric rates going up
(Detroit News, September 19, 2008)
An energy package that will raise residential electric rates by up to 12 percent, require more electricity to be generated by renewable sources and put a cap on competition to the major utilities won final passage in the Legislature Thursday.
Gov. Jennifer Granholm, who has been pushing for expansion of renewable energy for months, will sign the two bills in the long-awaited energy plan "as soon as they reach her desk," spokeswoman Liz Boyd said.
The legislation calls for 10 percent of Michigan's electric power to come from renewable sources such as wind, solar and hydroelectric power by 2015. Currently, about 3 percent of the state's electricity is generated by these sources. (full article)
Energy reforms approved
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, September 19, 2008)
More than a year in the making, massive reforms to the state's energy policy were approved Thursday by the Legislature and are expected to be signed by the governor next week.
Backers say it will grow jobs and the state will have reliable and cleaner power for years to come, while opponents argue electric bills will increase in a time when residents cannot afford it.
Consumers Energy spokesman Jeff Holyfield said an analysis done by the Jackson-based utility shows it will cause residential rates to increase between 8 percent to 10 percent over the next five years. (full article)
Lawmakers OK major energy legislation
(Associated Press, September 19, 2008)
Lawmakers on Thursday approved a plan that requires more electricity to come from renewable sources, raises residential rates, restricts competition among power companies, and aims to make homes and businesses more energy-efficient.
The result: Residential electric bills will go up by 8 percent to 20 percent over five years - but not by as much if the Legislature had done nothing, according to backers who said Michigan now is assured of reliable, cleaner power and not needing to build as many coal-fired plants.
House Energy and Technology Chairman Frank Accavitti said the three-bill package will be "a wash" for customers if they take advantage of new energy-efficiency programs. They might get rebates to buy compact fluorescent light bulbs and efficient appliances. (full article)
Mich. lawmakers sharpen BWL's edge
(Lansing State Journal, September 28, 2008)
The Legislature and Gov. Jennifer Granholm have "succeeded" in pushing up electric rates across Michigan.
One bit of good news to come out of the passage of this bad deal, though, is for the customers of Lansing's Board of Water & Light. They escape most of the impact of this mistake - another selling point for the Lansing area.
Under the state's legislation, residential customers of Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison can expect bills to rise 8 percent to 12 percent. (full article) August 2008
No Energy Deal, No Session
(MIRS, August 11, 2008)
Without a breakthrough on energy, the Senate canceled Wednesday's session today - the only session slated for August - and the House, hours later, followed suit. According to a well-placed source, no deal has been reached yet on the energy package and, without a deal, there's no reason to hold legislative sessions at this time. That means no action or discussion on recently jailed Detroit Mayor Kwame KILPATRICK, either.
"We could get it done if both sides wanted to," one legislator said. (full article)
No Energy Agreement Leads to Senate Canceling Session
(Gongwer News Service, August 11, 2008)
With no imminent agreement on energy and utility regulation, the Senate has cancelled its session on Wednesday.
Senate officials decided to hold off until September to take action, in hopes an agreement on the energy bills will be completed by then.
In the House, a spokesperson for Speaker Andy Dillon (D-Redford Twp.) said it was uncertain if the House would meet or not on Wednesday. (full article)
Lower electricity sales cited in energy-reform debate
(Crain's Detroit Business, August 11, 2008)
With action potentially looming on Michigan energy reforms, a coalition calling for more legislative review is pointing to Michigan electricity companies' second-quarter sales declines as another indication why neither legislation nor new plants should be rushed.
DTE Energy Co. and CMS Energy Corp. reported electricity sales down about 4 percent from the same quarter a year ago, reflecting the slower economy, the effects of the American Axle and Manufacturing Holdings Inc. strike, and other factors in addition to weather. (full article)
Advocates Urge Gov To Oppose Deskewing
(MIRS, August 11, 2008)
Several of the state's advocacy groups today urged the Governor to oppose the new energy legislation, which allows for the deskewing of the rate system, a move, they say, will hurt lower-income families in the face of soaring energy costs.
The current "skewed" energy system means that Michigan industries pay significantly higher utility rates than consumers, which they contend amounts to a consumer subsidy. Deskewing the system would lead to Michigan residential customers paying higher rates than they do now and industry paying lower rates. (full article)
State says lessons didn't stick for utilities after outages in 2003
(Detroit Free Presss, August 11, 2008)
Five years ago Thursday, overgrown trees took five Ohio transmission lines out of service, triggering a blackout that swept the Midwest, Northeast and parts of Canada.
More than 6 million people in Michigan and 50 million in all of North America were left in the dark.
In the wake of the outage - one of the largest in North American history - U.S. regulatory agencies cracked down on transmission companies that did not perform regular tree maintenance along the highvoltage lines that move electricity from generators to distribution companies. (full article)
Electricity monopoly would burden economy
(Booth Newspapers, August 12, 2008)
Michigan's economy is the worst-performing one in the nation, and the Saginaw area has been particularly hard hit by the state's economic woes.
The potential Hemlock Semiconductor Corp. expansion offers some hope of economic improvement. Originally, tax changes necessary for the Hemlock expansion were tied to a bill, House Bill 5524, which has been referred to falsely as "electricity market reform," but the bill as passed by the Senate removed this connection. (full article)
Chrysler plants could shift to 4-day week
(Detroit Free Press, August 12, 2008)
As energy costs skyrocket, Chrysler LLC is looking at ways to save money, including, perhaps, a move to workweeks of four 10-hour days at several of its factories.
"We're looking at doing four 10s across the shops to help reduce energy costs," Chrysler Executive Vice President of Manufacturing Frank Ewasyshyn told the Free Press on Monday.
A shorter workweek had been suggested earlier this summer by Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson as an option for employees. It has since spread to other governments and private businesses. (full article)
Much uncertainty remains five years after blackout
(Detroit Free Press, August 14, 2008)
Today is the fifth anniversary of a massive blackout that disrupted life for 50 million people in the United States and Canada, including much of Michigan, and caused economic losses estimated between $4 billion and $10 billion. The power grid system that failed is generally said to be in better shape today, but nobody is saying another large scale disaster is impossible.
The anniversary date comes as the Michigan Legislature remains stalled on utility legislation that has provoked controversy on all sides. (full article)
Essay: Alternative Energy
(Jack Lessenberry’s Essays and Interviews, August 18, 2008)
From time to time I get attacked for being too liberal.
So let me say that when it comes to the energy legislation now pending in the Michigan legislature, I stand one hundred percent with a conservative economist from Hillsdale College named Gary Wolfram. As far as I can determine he, more than anyone else, sees what an anticonsumer farce both packages of bills are. (full article)
Lawmakers prepare to raise rates
While voters snooze, pols poised to boost utility bills
(Lansing State Journal, August 19, 2008)
How would you feel if the Legislature and Gov. Jennifer Granholm decided to pass legislation raising the price of gasoline in the state at the request of ExxonMobil?
Now that I have your attention, let's talk about gas - natural gas, and coal and uranium and the electricity Michigan generates from these sources.
Sometime soon, the Legislature is expected to pass some version of legislation to reduce competition in the electric markets. Granholm is expected to sign it. And it's also expected that the average residential user buying power from Consumers Energy or DTE will see their monthly bills rise. One Senate analysis put the increase between 20 percent and 30 percent. (full article)
Flexible rules needed for new energy sources
(Detroit News, August 19, 2008)
Of course Michigan should develop alternative and renewable energy sources. The question is whether it will do so in a cost-effective way that doesn't damage its economic competitiveness.
Michigan is already an expensive state in which to do business. And electricity costs are part of that higher-than-average cost. With the loss of more than 400,000 jobs in the last few years and an unemployment rate that is the highest in the nation, the state can't afford to further hurt its economic climate. (full article)
Asleep at the switch
(Jack Lessenberry Essary, August 20, 2008)
Your state legislators (remember them?) do mostly have utter disrespect for your ability to figure out what they are doing to you. That's made a lot easier, as they know very well, because the newspapers don't much cover what they do anymore.
Three months ago, I told you about this wonderful new plan they had to really screw us over the cost of energy ("Getting jacked again," May 7). The House and the Senate then were quickly moving to pass a package of what were billed as "renewable energy" bills. (full article)
Granholm: Blame Bishop On Energy
(MIRS, August 22, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM will moderate a town hall meeting on alternative energy at the Democratic National Convention on Tuesday, but she won't have a renewable package signed into law that she can bring with her.
The Governor said she enlisted Texas oilman (and big Republican donor) T. Boone PICKENS to write a letter to the person she fingered at a press conference today for holding up the process. (full article)
Residential electric rates to skyrocket under electric remonopolization and renewable energy legislation - CCC Press Release
(August 25, 2008)
As Michigan residents face record national gas, propane and heating oil bills this winter, lawmakers are considering bills that would add huge electric rate hikes to residential electric bills in January while requiring the utilities to do nothing to increase renewable power until 2012. The renewable power plan under consideration would be the most expensive in the nation.
While supporters of the remonopolization and renewable package focus public attention on the final goal of having 10 percent renewable power by 2015, little attention is being put on unnecessary surcharges being put on customer bills due to the legislation, and the delays in providing new renewable power required under the Legislation. (full release)
Shine some light on electricity package
(Lansing State Journal, August 26, 2008)
For months, the Legislature has had before it a wide-ranging set of bills to rewrite electric policy in Michigan. The expectation in Lansing is that a small group of lawmakers meeting in secret will soon produce a compromise package, which will be rushed through the Legislature and to Gov. Jennifer Granholm in a matter of days.
Why? What's the hurry over at the Capitol? If Michigan could go these many months without what advocates call vital reform, why can't the public chew over the final deal? (full article)
year after announcing plans to build a new power
(Bay City Times, August 31, 2008)
Consumers Energy is keeping positive about its prospects for building a $2.3 billion power plant in Bay County's Hampton Township.
But a year after the company announced its big building plans, some significant hurdles continue to short circuit the start of the project.
State lawmakers are wrangling right now over a complex rewriting of state energy law that Consumers says is needed to build the plant. The legislation could come to a vote as early as Sept. 9. (full article) July 2008 It's lights out for smarter energy policy in state Senate
(Detroit Free Press, July 1, 2008)
Hold on to your light switches. The state Senate, in the late hours of Friday night, passed about the worst possible combination of utility bills imaginable.
First, the Senate stripped virtually all meaning out of a bill calling for a minimum amount of renewable energy and a program to promote energy efficiency. Then senators passed a bill reregulating the state's utilities, allowing their competition never to exceed 10% of the market. (full article)
Energy Bills Could Mean Lights Out On Low Prices
(MIRS, July 2, 2008)
Michigan's proposed renewable energy plan could cost residential utility users a bundle while Michigan utility giants DTE and Consumers Energy pocket millions, opponents of the plan said today in a Capitol roundtable discussion.
According to Consumer Choice Coalition (CCC) Executive Director Barry CARGILL, if the measures are signed into the law, residential energy prices could go up between 20 and 27 percent without residents ever seeing an increase in the amount of energy produced. (full article)
Keep Michigan's Successful Electricity Competition Law
(Mackinac Center Viewpoint on Public Issues, July 7, 2008)
The Michigan legislature is considering a package of bills designed to decrease the amount of competition in Michigan's electricity markets and impose mandates for the use of certain "renewable energies," such as solar power. The bills are marketed as job creators that would help provide a reliable supply of energy, but in fact, the record shows they would raise the cost of electricity and deliver a painful blow to Michigan's economy.
Michigan introduced competition in the supply of electricity in 2000 with Public Act 141. The act allowed consumers to purchase electricity through their existing electrical lines from suppliers competing with the state's regional monopoly utilites (primarily DTE Energy and Consumers Energy). When the law was passed, michigan electricity rates were among the highest in the country, and they were higher than ratesin any of the neighboring states. (full article)
Senate energy bill called inadequate
(Crain's Detroit Business, July 7, 2008)
A renewable-energy mandate passed by the state Senate is being criticized for doing too little to encourage the development of such resources.
Senate Bill 213, part of a package of energy reforms sent to the House, calls for a 7 percent renewable portfolio standard by 2015. But that doesn't mean the utilities must obtain 7 percent of their electricity from such sources.
The bill allows 30 percent of that target to be met through energy-efficiency programs and 20 percent to be met through “clean energy systems” such as a plant being built in Alma that could generate energy from coal, coal waste byproducts and biomass while capturing carbon dioxide emissions and reducing pollutants. (full article)
June 2008
Utilities shouldn't have a monopoly
(Crain's Detroit Business, June 2, 2008)
Lansing lawmakers face a critical decision: Should Michigan restore the monopoly that the state's dominant energy companies— Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison Co. — had before customer-choice reform in 2000?
Consumers and Edison argue that they cannot make investments in new power-generating plants without some type of guarantee that their investment will be paid for through a strong customer base. Customer choice removes that guarantee. They want lawmakers to guarantee 90 percent of the market will be divided between them. The two companies have contributed nearly all of the $1.9 million spent so far on advertising in support of their plan by the Michigan Jobs and Energy Coalition. (full article)
Michigan may raise residents' electric bills to help businesses
(Associated Press, June 2, 2008)
State lawmakers plan to raise residential electric bills by as much as 15 percent so businesses and schools can pay less.
Prices historically have been "skewed" by state regulators so residents pay less than the actual cost of electricity, while businesses pay more.
Legislators acknowledge residential customers would experience some sticker shock, but many no longer want to force business customers to subsidize residential rates, in part because they think Michigan's business rates -- which traditionally run higher than surrounding states -- discourage companies from locating here. (full article)
Alternative-energy plans moving from ‘if’ to ‘when’
(Crain's Detroit Business, June 2, 2008)
Forces are converging to advance Michigan’s alternative-energy industry.
The question is: How far and how fast it will happen?
Michigan’s two leading energy companies continued to press their cases at the Detroit Regional Chamber’s Mackinac Policy Conference with executives sporting “Juice for Jobs” pins from a coalition pushing for prompt approval of a comprehensive package of energy legislation pending in the state Senate. (full article)
Former P.S.C. Commissioners Raise Worries About House Energy Bills
(Gongwer News Service, June 5, 2008)
A House-passed package of bills that would substantially restructure energy generation and utility regulation in the state would seriously impede the ability of the Public Service Commission to protect consumers and lead to higher consumer costs, a group of former PSC members said in a letter to the Legislature.
Seven former members of the commission, representing commissioners appointed by former Governors William Milliken, James Blanchard and John Engler, signed the letter that outlined five areas of concern about HB 5524, HB 5525, HB 5548 and HB 5549. (full article)
Energy Advocates Spar Again
(MIRS, June 5, 2008)
As the Senate Energy Policy Committee weighs the House Renewable Portfolio (RPS) chunk of the
energy package, seven former members of the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) today came
out swinging against various parts of the plan.
"The Legislation coming over from the House handcuffs the Public Service Commission, overturns 100
years of decisions and forces customers to pay more," said former MPSC Chair Eric SCHNEIDEWIND,
who has long opposed House versions. (full article)
Former Michigan Public Service Commissioners oppose major sections of energy remonopolization bills - CCC Press Release
(June 5, 2008)
Seven former members of the Michigan Public Service Commission, including Democrats, Republicans and Independents who served from the 1970s to 2007, have announced their opposition to major parts of the energy package now before the Senate.
“We believe these bills have serious flaws and would create unnecessarily high rates for Michigan ratepayers without providing for proper levels of electric development in our state,” said the seven commissioners, including three former chairs of the commission and those appointed as Democrats, Republicans and Independents. (full release) (Former Commissioner Letter)
Patterson: Progress Is Being Made On Energy Bills
(Gongwer News Service, June 10, 2008)
While little legislation overhauling Michigan's utility and energy regulatory system has moved so far from the Senate Energy Policy and Public Utilities Committee, its chair, Sen. Bruce Patterson (R-Canton), said committee members are working towards resolution of the issues.
But that does not necessarily mean there will be a "straight line to an outcome," Mr. Patterson said, a point he said he had also made to House Speaker Andy Dillon (D-Redford Twp.). (full article)
Senate committee approves energy bills backed by utilities
(Crain's Detroit Business, June 12, 2008)
A state Senate committee on Thursday approved energy legislation that, among other things, sets new requirements for use of renewable energy and restricts electricity customers’ ability to choose alternate suppliers.
The bills approved by the Senate Energy Policy and Public Utilities Committee now go to the full Senate.
Hailing the Thursday action was the Michigan Jobs and Energy Coalition, which supported the House-passed package and said it would provide affordable electricity and a structure to encourage development of new plants. (full article)
Patterson Moves House Energy Bills
(MIRS, June 12, 2008)
After a Senate panel today unexpectedly kicked out the House energy bills - including Public Act 141 reform - one stunned audience member declared, "I'm buying Consumers stock."
Energy Policy Committee Chair Bruce PATTERSON (R-Canton) this afternoon moved Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) reforms (HB 5548 and HB 5549) and controversial HB 5524, which turns Michigan's electric industry into more of a regulated market, which Consumers Energy and DTE have pushed. (full article)
Senate Panel Approves Most Of Electric Restructuring
(Gongwer News Service, June 12, 2008)
Three of the four bills in the House energy package moved one step, at least procedurally, closer to the governor's desk Thursday. But it was still not clear after the Senate Energy Policy and Public Utilities Committee's action what the bills might look like as they move back to the House, or when the full Senate may approve the package.
Those supporting the package that would give greater market power to the state's major utilities praised the committee's action, but those seeking more customer choice in the market were "dumbfounded" by the move.
(full article)
Derek Melot: Electric claim is silly policy
(Lansing State Journal, June 15, 2008)
If power must be home-grown, what of food?
Quick survey: What's the point of origin of the shirt on your back?
Where was your car assembled and the components made?
That bell pepper in the crisper and flank steak in the freezer ... know where they came from?
Odds are, unless your car was assembled nearby, none of the items was made or grown in Michigan.
So why is the Legislature supposed to be worried about the source of electricity?
Michigan's big utilities - Consumers Energy and DTE - are behind a vigorous ad campaign designed to rewrite state utility law. Under the guise of the "Michigan Jobs and Energy Coalition," the utilities want to convince you they are all about renewable power - and are mighty afraid of having to buy juice from their fellow Americans or shady Canadians. (full article)
Theodore Bolema: Utilities' plan would fatten their wallets
(Lansing State Journal, June 15, 2008)
The Michigan Senate is considering a package of bills to largely end the state's six years of limited competition in the supply of electricity. While the bills' stated goals may be laudable, the current policy debate is being driven largely by special interests, not consumer interests.
DTE Energy and Consumers Energy, Michigan's two largest utilities, are trying to regain much of their state-sanctioned monopoly status by claiming these bills would lower electricity costs, promote investment in new power plants and create jobs. (full article)
Energy Debate Dominates Senate GOP Caucus
(MIRS, June 25, 2008)
"Energy" was the watchword of the day in hours of Senate Republican caucuses. Though budgets were on senators' minds, the energy package dominated the closed-door meetings as the chamber mulls action before summer break.
Energy company lobbyists from both the incumbents and the competitive suppliers were turning up the heat on legislators in an already muggy building today. Sources also tell MIRS Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM also has been engaged on the issue, as well. (full article)
Senate Zaps RPS Down To 7%
(MIRS, June 27, 2008)
Michigan would need to get 7 percent of its energy from environmentally friendly sources by 2015 under a Senate energy reform package pushed out of the upper chamber 20-17 late tonight by a unified Republican caucus.
The change not only knocks down the 10 percent renewable portfolio standard (RPS) passed by the House and supported by the Governor, but allows out-of-state alternative energy, "clean coal" and energy efficiencies to be counted in the goal to the protest of the minority Democrats. (full article)
Energy Bills Jolt Senate
(Gongwer News Service, June 28, 2008)
Energy regulation legislation sparked and temporarily shorted out, but then was regenerated and passed during a late night session in the Senate on Friday.
Just before midnight the main bill in the package, HB 5524*, passed on a 21-14 voted. Less than an hour earlier it had failed on a 13-13 vote as most Senate Democrats refused to participate in the vote.
But in the final vote, nine Democrats joined with 12 Republicans to secure its passage.
The chamber barely passed a bill, SB 213*, calling for a 7 percent renewal portfolio standard by 2015, but Democrats said the measure will actually result in less electricity created by renewable methods because the 7 percent standard includes energy conservation and will only require that 4 percent of electricity is generated by renewable sources, less than the 5 percent standard now in place. (full article)
May 2008
Switch to 'green' energy could hit Michigan hard
(Windsor Star, May 2, 2008)
The energy package now briskly moving through the Michigan legislature sounds like an environmentalist's and consumer's dream. They are being billed as the "green energy bills."
They call on power companies to provide more energy from "renewable" sources, which is bound to make many voters think of Gov. Jennifer Granholm's often expressed desire for wind power. (full article)
Eastpointe legislator is energy point man
(Macomb Daily News, May 4, 2008)
In the high-powered political battle in Lansing over electricity rates andfuture energy supplies, Frank Accavitti is the man on the hot seat.
The Democratic state representative from Eastpointe pushed through asweeping legislative package that would increase the rates Michigan homeowners and businesses pay for electric power. The main bill, approved by Accavitti's House committee after 16 months of legislative work, is designed to provide a steady stream of power from the state's utilities for decades to come. (full article)
Time for state to plug in to green energy
(Detroit Free Press, May 4, 2008)
Like it or not, the world's skyrocketing demand for energy -- and the related volatility of energy prices -- is turning our world topsy-turvy.
Michigan is particularly unsettled with its historical economic dependence on production of automobiles highly influenced by the gyrations in the price of fossil fuels.
Indeed, we saw stark evidence last week of a rapid swing in consumer preference from big trucks and SUVs to more fuel-efficient cars, triggering big drops of 12% to 24% in the April sales of the Detroit Three automakers. (full article)
Tech firm wooed with $357M tax credit
(Detroit News, May 5, 2008)
Michiganians struggling to pay their own electric bills could be stunned to learn they may have to help pick up a multimillion-dollar power tab in a few years for a highly successful silicon manufacturer in the Saginaw Valley.
Hemlock Semiconductor is in line for a state tax credit against its Michigan Business Tax bill for a dozen years starting in 2012, a break that could cost the state's general fund as much as $357 million, according to a Senate Fiscal Agency analysis. The tax-supported general fund, the state's main checkbook, pays for universities, prisons, human services and other state programs and services. (full article)
Wind Association Blows Off Energy Plan
(MIRS, May 6, 2008)
A leading wind energy association blew off the House-passed energy package today, saying the legislation would actually put $2 billion in new investment in wind energy projects at risk.
In letters to Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM and Senate Energy Policy Committee Chair Bruce PATTERSON (R-Canton), the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) urged the leaders to make a "fresh start" with annual renewable energy requirements much more aggressive than what passed the House two weeks ago (See "House Passes Energy Package," 4/17/08). (full article) (AWEA letter to Gov. Granholm) (AWEA letter to Sen. Patterson)
Wind Generators Oppose House Energy Package
(Gongwer News Service, May 6, 2008)
The package of bills recently passed the House to increase investment in electric generation in the state, and particularly in renewable power, will not meet that goal, the American Wind Energy Association said in a letter to Governor Jennifer Granholm and Sen. Bruce Patterson (RCanton), whose committee is now considering the legislation.
The bills to implement a renewable portfolio standard and energy efficiency programs (HB 5548and HB 5549) would require the major utilities to use 4 percent renewable power by 2012 and 15 percent by 2015. (full article)
House bills mean huge residential electric rate hikes, increases for many businesses, Senate Fiscal Agency says - Customer Choice Coalition Press Release
(May 8, 2008)
House-passed electric remonopolization legislation will raise Detroit Edison residential electric rates by 28 percent and Consumers Energy residential rates by 23.2 to 25.2 percent – before even considering the costs of a new electric plant or fuel cost increases – according to an analysis by the Senate Fiscal Agency issued Wednesday.
The legislation passed by the House will take away the rights of virtually all customers to choose alternative electric providers by eliminating competition for 90 percent of the two utilities electric load. Competition has held down electric rates in Michigan since 2000. (full press release)
Energy bills could jump $200 next year
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, May 9, 2008)
Consumers Energy residential customers could pay as much as $1,100 a year for electricity if a package of energy bills is approved, according to a nonpartisan legislative agency.
Gary Olson, the director of the Senate Fiscal Agency, told a senate committee that Consumers Energy customers would see an increase of more than $200 next year if the bills, which were approved by the state House last month, were signed into law. (full article)
Preserve Energy Alternatives' Momentum
(Grand Rapids Business Jouranl, May 12, 2008)
On May Day the governor of Ohio signed into law renewable energy legislation, making the Buckeye State the 26th in the nation prepared to compete for related jobs and new business; reduced residential, commercial and industrial energy costs; and capture of an estimated $1.3 billion to $1.5 billion in new renewable energy investments.
More than half of all states now have approved such legislation to move rapidly into the future of alternative resources. In Michigan, where Great Lakes wind power is estimated to be second only to some Plains States, no such leadership can be found.
Michigan House Democrats tie-barred Michigan's promising legislative package to a bill gutting the state's utility deregulation. Grand Rapids Business Journal in March criticized the allegiance to both DTE Energy Co. and Consumers Energy, recalling the crybaby tactics used when deregulation was artfully moved through the legislature by then Gov. John Engler, despite the utility companies whining about "stranded costs." (full article)
Energy: Michigan can invest in renewable power without utility deal
(Lansing State Journal, May 16, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm and the Michigan House are on record as wanting the state to invest more in, and require more use of, renewable energy.
It's a shame the method they've chosen to advance the renewable goal is fatally flawed - mainly because it's built on two false assumptions:
• Michigan clearly needs a significant amount of new power generation in-state.
• The only way to get investments in renewable power is through utility giants DTE and Consumers Energy.
(full article)
Michigan's utility scam
(Toledo Blade, May 19, 2008)
Michigan's two largest electric companies are enthusiastic about a package of "green energy" bills that the state House overwhelmingly passed, and which are now before the Senate. They tout these as being consumer-friendly and environmentally sound. The legislation would, they say, both enable them to do more to meet coming Michigan's power needs and commit the utilities in a major way to greater use of "renewable energy," meaning wind and solar power.
What could possibly be wrong with that?
Nothing - until you actually read the bills, which are co-sponsored by state Sen. Randy Richardville (R., Monroe). What they really would do is give the big two - CMS Energy Corp. and DTE Energy - new monopoly powers by severely limiting the ability of alternative energy suppliers to compete. Worse, they would allow future proposed rate increases to take place automatically if the Michigan Public Service Commission doesn't act to stop them. (full article)
Who gets power with energy bills?
(Grand Rapids Press, Saturday, May 24, 2008)
Imagine being a business owner who was able to guarantee locking up 90 percent marketshare.
That's the idea behind new Michigan energy legislation backed by Consumers Energy and DTE Energy that already has been passed by the state House and is being considered by the state Senate.
The legislation would guarantee 90 percent of Michigan's market for electricity would be controlled by Consumers or DTE, a move the state's incumbent electric suppliers say is necessary for them to invest in new plants and alternative power generation technology. (full article)
Electricity Choice Law Bills Aired
(Grand Rapids Business Journal, May 26, 2008)
A brief “seminar” was scheduled last week at Grand Valley State University by opponents of the proposed legislation that would scale back Michigan's "choice" law that enables residents and businesses to choose the source of electricity they get from regulated utilities.
"We are very concerned about the bills that passed the House and are hoping we can make some substantial changes on the Senate side," said Mary Dechow, director of Government and Regulatory Affairs for Spartan Stores. (full article)
April 2008 Consumers CEO Makes Case For Energy Bills
(MIRS, April 4, 2008)
The head of CMS Energy told MIRS today that he's found "frustrating" the quantity of "misinformation" floating around Lansing about the pending House energy reform legislation.
David JOOS said, no, the bills House Speaker Andy DILLON (D-Redford Twp.), Rep. Frank ACCAVITTI (D- Eastpointe) and Rep. Mike NOFS (R-Battle Creek) are working on doesn't allow the state's two major utilities to pass along to residents any and all power plant construction cost overruns. The Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) still must sign off. (full article)
Electric utilities fight to keep turf
(Detroit News, April 4, 2008)
More than $1 million has been spent on lobbying and campaign donations in the high-stakes battle over an energy package that will impact every Michiganian who flips on a light switch.
Most of the spending is by DTE Energy and Consumers Energy -- the two major utilities looking to protect and expand their turf by scaling back an 8-year-old law that opened Michigan's electricity market to competition. (full article)
Utilities spend money to influence rewrite of electricity law
(Associated Press, April 6, 2008)
Utilities that want a rewrite of Michigan's 8-year-old electricity law are outspending their opponents when it comes to lobbying lawmakers and giving to their campaigns.
Detroit Edison and Jackson-based Consumers Energy, which together distribute power to nearly 90 percent
of the state's electric customers, spent at least $525,600 last year lobbying the Legislature and Gov. Jennifer Granholm's administration — three times what competitors spent. (full article)
Six Burning Questions on P.A. 141
(MIRS, April 11, 2008)
The House leadership's plans to bake limits on the state's electric choice law into new alternative energy mandates and energy efficiency programs have sparked significant debate over Michigan's energy policy in recent months.
House Speaker Andy Dillion (D-Redford Twp.) has made the issue his top priority of 2008, and it's shown. His shop has coordinated several meetings, hearings and workshops on the issue over the last several weeks. (full article)
Hemlock Semiconductor Tax Break Tacked Onto House Energy Package
(Gongwer News Service, April 14, 2008)
As the House Energy and Technology Committee prepares on Wednesday to take up its rewrite to electric choice, commonly referred to as PA 141, a package of bills granting Michigan Business Tax credits to Hemlock Semiconductor Corporation based on how much energy the company uses have been tie-barred to it.
In order to receive the tax credits starting in 2012 and running through 2024, the maker of polysilicon crystalline would have to enter into an agreement with the Michigan Economic Development Corporation saying it will construct or operate a new or expanded facility in the state. (full article)
Customer Choice Coalition unveils second radio ad against House Bill 5524 -
CCC Press Release
(April 15, 2008)
As the House Energy and Technology Committee prepares to consider House Bill 5524, the Customer Choice Coalition is running radio ads informing voters that the bills will lead to huge electric rate hikes and job losses due to those electric rate hikes.
“The Customer Choice Coalition has taken the lead in providing factual information to lawmakers and citizens about this massive and unnecessary electric rate hike bill,” said Barry Cargill. “We are proud to be running this week on statewide radio another spot that lets Michigan know the House is ready to impose a $2 billion tax increase on Michigan by remonopolizing the state’s electric system and taking away their right to choose.” (full press release)
Customer Choice Hits Airwaves Second Time
(MIRS, April 15, 2008)
The sparks continue to fly over the so called energy package (HB 5524, HB 5525, HB 5548 and HB 5549). Today, the Customer Choice Coalition (CCC) announced a second radio ad campaign it hopes would inform voters that "the bills would lead to huge electric rate hikes and job losses."
"The Customer Choice Coalition has taken the lead in providing factual information to lawmakers and citizens about this massive and unnecessary electric rate hike bill," said Barry Cargill. "We are proud to be running this week on statewide radio another spot that lets Michigan know the House is ready to impose a $2 billion tax increase on Michigan by remonopolizing the state's electric system and taking away their right to choose." (full article) March 2008 House electric bills take competition, entrepreneurs out of Michigan electric markets - (CCC Press Release)
(March 3, 2008)
Legislation pending in the House Energy and Technology Committee will tell renewable and conventional energy entrepreneurs that Michigan is closed for business, Customer Choice Coalition supporters said at a news conference today.
“Competition, choice and free markets are better solutions to Michigan’s energy policies than monopolies, increased regulation and restrictions on entrepreneurs,” said Sen. Wayne Kuipers, R-Holland, sponsor of SB 427, which would call for all energy providers to compete to meet future electricity needs. “When many companies are vying to enter Michigan’s electric market, as is happening today, customers should be allowed to benefit from the competition that will hold rates down and ensure more reliable – and renewable – energy to meet the state’s future needs.”
(full release)
Nofs: We're 90% There
(MIRS, March 4, 2008)
Major progress is reported on efforts to rewrite the state's energy laws and Rep. Mike NOFS (R-Battle Creek) said, after a six hour session, only about 10 percent of the package is left to be ironed out, but he quickly notes that is the tough part.
"I don't think we'll ever get everybody on board but if you can negate some of the loses or the degree of loses for those people who aren't going to get their way, that makes the bill better and some people go neutral instead of opposing it — that is important," Nofs said. (full article)
Big 3 Goes For Round 2 On Energy Costs
(MIRS, March 6, 2008)
The Big Three said a House energy plan would cost consumers billions, but the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) said doing nothing to change the state's energy policy is the most expensive option.
The Detroit automakers, who last week received a tongue-lashing from Senate Energy Policy Committee Chair Bruce PATTERSON (R-Canton) for their reticence to testify, were back before the committee today. (full article)
Schools Join Lobby Against PA 141 Bills
(Gongwer News Service, March 6, 2008)
The Michigan School Business Officials asked its members to join the fray over electric market restructuring bills this week.
In an email to members, the association said the current law "has literally saved schools tens of millions of dollars over the past ten years." The email urged members to call legislators and voice their opposition to HB 5520, HB 5521, HB 5522, HB 5523 and HB 5524. (full article)
Price of Electricity Hinges on Michigan Legislature
(WILX TV-10 Lansing, March 7, 2008)
The price of your electricity for years to come could hinge on what the Legislature does in 2008.
Big utilities are lobbying state lawmakers for a rewrite of energy rules before they will agree to build new, multibillion-dollar power plants to be paid for by customers. Gov. Jennifer Granholm is pushing for new laws this month requiring the utilities to supply more renewable energy, a move she says would bring new jobs to a hurting economy and let Michigan produce more of its own energy. Environmentalists are arguing for more energy conservation and trying to stop Michigan from joining a nationwide construction boom in coal-fired power plants. Such plants emit major amounts of carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas linked to global warming. (full article)
Electric rates could jolt state Saturday
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, March 08, 2008)
Michigan businesses and residents are using more energy and will be paying more for it in the years to come.
Just how much more is the focus of a complicated debate in Lansing over Michigan's energy future
A package of bills in the state House could increase customer cost by as much as 28 percent in two years, according to the Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity. (full article)
Costs, other concerns spark debate over requiring green power
(Associated Press, March 8, 2008)
If Michigan is to join 25 states requiring that more electricity come from renewablesources, the Legislature must sort out all kinds of issues — including the price tag.
Compared with existing power from old, already-paid-for coal plants, renewable energy is more expensive.The House is considering capping residents' extra costs at no more than $3 a month, or $36 a year over 20years, which could let power companies off the hook for meeting the renewable energy requirement, known as an RPS. (full article)
What will green power cost? Surcharge, spending cap considered
(Crain's Detroit Business, March 10, 2008)
Michigan's drive to renewable energy is generatingconcern about higher electricity prices.
The issue: How, and at what price, will utilities or other energy providers build or purchase renewable power to meet a proposed state mandate that 10 percent of power come from renewable sources by 2015? (full article)
Mike Cox: Energy proposals would raise rates
(Crain's Detroit Business, March 11, 2008)
Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox on Tuesday weighed in against legislation being considered to restructure Michigan utility regulation and narrow the ability of utility customers to choose alternate electricity suppliers.
Cox said proposals, which include requiring a percentage of Michigan’s power to come from renewable sources, would raise electricity rates by some $2.5 billion. (full article)
Cox: Electricity legislation would bring large rate increase
(The Associated Press, March 11, 2008)
Attorney General Mike Cox on Tuesday blasted legislation he said would significantly raise electricity rates by requiring more alternative energy and decreasing competition.
Cox, a Republican, added that having more green energy is laudable. But he said Democratic Gov. Jennifer Granholm is over-promising its job-creation potential. (full article)
Cox's Puts $2.8B Price Tag On Energy Bills
(MIRS Capitol Capsule, March 11, 2008)
Attorney General Mike COX today announced he is opposing the proposed "radical" re-regulation of the state's electric industry, saying the House plan will cost consumers anywhere between $2 and $2.8 billion, as much as 40 percent increase on current electric bills.
The legislation sets renewable energy standards and energy efficiency initiatives, but restricts consumer advocate oversight, opening up consumers to foot the bill for any new power plant cost overruns, Cox said. (full article)
Cox Opposes PA 141 Changes, R.P.S. as Economic Development
(Gongwer News Service, March 11, 2008 )
Attorney General Mike Cox urged the Legislature to reject efforts by Detroit Edison and Consumers Energy to eliminate electric customer choice in the name of additional capacity. And he said efforts to impose a renewable portfolio standard should be sold as an effort to help the environment, not the economy.
Whatever the goals of the proposal being discussed in the House, the outcome is going to be annual rate increases of as much as 40 percent, Mr. Cox said. (full article) Customer Choice Coalition unveils radio ad campaign against House Bill 5524 -
CCC Press Release
(March 17, 2008)
As the House Energy and Technology Committee prepares to consider House Bill 5524, the Customer Choice Coalition is running radio ads informing Michigan of the consequences of the legislation to remonopolize the state’s electric system.
“We have been telling lawmakers that this legislation is bad for the state. Now we are taking the discussion to voters. We know Michigan residents like the ability to choose their electric provider, and will oppose the more that $2 billion in electric rate increases this bill will impose on them,” said Barry Cargill, executive director of the Customer Choice Coalition. (full release) (click here to hear the radio ad)
House Makes Late Electric Push
(MIRS, March 17, 2008)
House-crafted legislation that puts new limits on the state's electrical restructuring effort has a 50/50 shot of moving out of committee, said a chief architect of the package.
Rep. Frank ACCAVITTI (D-Eastpointe), chair of the House Energy and Technology Committee, said today he's hoping to tweak HB 5524 enough to kick it out of committee before the House goes on its two-week recess. (full article)
Electric Competitors, Customers Take to Airwaves
(Gongwer News Service, March 17, 2008)
With the House Energy and Technology Committee poised to report legislation this week that would implement a renewable portfolio standard and amend the state's electric choice program in the process, the Customer Choice Coalition launched radio ads Monday opposing the electric choice changes.
(full artilce)
Consumer Choice Poll Finds Support For Energy Deregulation
(MIRS, March 18, 2008)
A poll commissioned by the Consumer Choice Coalition, which opposes House plans to revamp Michigan's hybrid utility system, shows 75 percent of Michigan voters say electric customers should have the right to buy power from competing electric providers.
The poll conducted by Marketing Resource Group said 64 percent are less likely to vote for lawmakers who have "taken away their right to choose an electric supplier and forced them to use a monopoly electric company."
(full article)
Electric Bills to See More Work
(Gongwer News Service, March 18, 2008)
A package of bills to again restructure the state's electric market and to require that utilities use renewable energy was supposed to move to the House floor Wednesday. But House Energy and Technology Committee Chair Rep. Frank Accavitti (D-Eastpointe) cancelled the meeting Tuesday to allow for additional negotiations.
Mr. Accavitti told Gongwer News Service that workgroups had been working on pieces of the package over the past several months, but various parties had been arguing recently that they could accept provisions in pieces in one workgroup if they could get changes to pieces in another. (full article)
P.A. 141 Repeal Staying Put
(MIRS, March 18, 2008)
Sources tell MIRS that HB 4562, legislation that would repeal Michigan customer choice legislation that provides for competition in the energy market, is a no-go this week.
By no means would the bill have been guaranteed traction in the Senate anyway, but there had been some talk of moving it out of the House Energy and Tech Committee and even passing it on the House floor before the spring break, which starts next week. The committee cancelled its meeting for Wednesday.
Apparently, there is some new angle on the problematic bill that House leadership wants to explore before starting to move the legislation.
Survey shows Michigan voters oppose remonopolizing electricity
Voters likely to oppose lawmakers who take away electric choice - CCC Press Release
(March 18, 2008)
Three out of four Michigan voters say electric customers should have the right to buy power from competing electric providers, and 64 percent are less likely to vote for lawmakers who support remonopolizing the state’s electric system, according to a new Marketing Resource Group survey conducted for the Customer Choice Coalition.
(full release)
Electricity use debate slows new state laws
(Associated Press, March 22, 2008)
A popular argument for rewriting Michigan's energy laws this year is that more electricity will be needed by 2015 -- not a lot of time for new power plants to be built.
But predicting energy usage is tricky.
Big utilities and others have tried to bolster their case for legislative changes by citing a January 2007 report from then-Michigan Public Service Commission Chairman J. Peter Lark. (full article)
Unbundle The Energy Legislation
(Grand Rapids Business Journal, March 24, 2008)
A reader recently remarked to Business Journal staff that Gov. Jennifer Granholm's administration has been more damaging to the state of Michigan than the painful auto-related economic evolution.
There is once again proof that politics, not solid public policy, rule in Lansing. Democrats in the Michigan House of Representatives have very deliberately knotted together the necessary and popular package of bills to set renewable Portfolio Standards with repeal of the Electric Choice and Reliability Act passed in 2000. House Speaker Pro-Tempore Michael Sak, R-Grand Rapids, who certainly is in the position to guide legislative efforts, told the Business Journal last week there is "not likely much we can do" to free the RPS package from the debacle of gutting utility deregulation. The remark is unforgettable and unforgivable. (full article)
Energy Legislation Debated
(Grand Rapids Business Journal, March 24, 2008)
Many Michigan commercial and industrial electrical energy customers, along with some nonprofit organizations, are gearing up to battle a package of proposed legislation in Lansing. That package includes the Renewable Portfolio Standard — not because business opposes "green" electricity but because another part of the package would repeal PA 141: the Electric Choice and Reliability Act passed in 2000. (full article)
Gathering Redefines 'Work Group'
(MIRS, March 25, 2008)
The hottest ticket in downtown Lansing this morning was the House Energy and Technology work group,
which met in the Mackinac Room on the 5th floor of the House Office Building.
A very large crowd filled the large room, which stretched the definition of "work group."
"This is not our normal work group," Committee Chair Frank ACCAVITTI, Jr. (D-Eastpointe) explained to
one out-of-town attendee. Accavitti and others repeatedly caught themselves using the words "testify"
only to correct the phrase with "I mean comment." (full article)
Workgroup Mulls Amendments to Energy Package
(Gongwer News Service, March 25, 2008)
The Mackinac Room in the House Office Building was crammed Tuesday for a workgroup session on an energy package including largely re-regulating the electric industry and mandating energy efficiency and a renewable portfolio standard. But while officials from energy groups, businesses, chambers of commerce, unions, alternative energy suppliers and the Granholm administration voiced the changes they would make to each of the bills in the package, there was still no consensus on possible amendments reached when the seven-hour meeting concluded.
House Energy and Technology Committee Chair Rep. Frank Accavitti (D-Eastpointe) said another workgroup meeting scheduled for Thursday would be canceled and that amendments proposed during Tuesday's gatherings would be reviewed and incorporated into the latest drafts for HB 5548 , HB 5549 , HB 5524 and HB 5525 . (full article)
It's a Matter of Choice
(Oakland Press, March 30, 2008)
Sharp debate over energy policy in Michigan is likely in the coming weeks and months.
The stakes are high, revolving around levels of electric utility competition, customer choice, electric rates, long-term supply and alternative energy sources.
Proponents say that three measures pending in the state House of Represent-atives will provide the stability that the major utilities need in order to build new generating plants while still exploring so-called renewable energy sources like wind and solar power. (full article)
February 2008 Power Plant Company Defends P.A. 141
(MIRS, February 1, 2008)
A chief official for a St. Louis-based company planning to build a coal-fired power plant in Midland is urging the Legislature to not make drastic changes to the state's electric choice law, P.A. 141, as it debates how to put renewable portfolio standards and energy efficiency standards into law.
LS Power is in the process of putting $1.3 billion into a new plant and they have a keen interest in what happens in the Legislature, where the momentum, in the House, at least, is to put the state's biggest incumbent utilities — Consumers Energy and DTE — in a better position to build much-needed power plants. (full article)
Electric Choice Down Again In '07
(MIRS, February 1, 2008)
Michigan's electric choice market last year was down to its lowest levels since its inaugural year in 2001 having reported only four percent of energy sales, down from six percent in 2006, according to a Public Service Commission (MPSC) today.
The number of choice customers and the amount of energy those customers used was down 33 and 14 percent, the report stated, which is a slower decline than the two previous years. (full article) DTE, CMS set to spend $6B: Investment key to alt-energy industry in state
(Crain's Detroit Business, February 4, 2008)
It was an attention-catching number: $6 billion in alternative-energy investment that Gov. Jennifer Granholm last week said Michigan utilities are poised to begin to make.
The investment, largely in wind power, could attract wind turbine manufacturers and other industry suppliers to the state and position Michigan as a major player in alternative energy and related economic development. (full article)
Latest On Blues Bills, P.A. 141
(MIRS, February 11, 2008)
The next two weeks could prove crucial in deciding whether the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan's (BCBSM) individual market reform reaches Gov. Jennifer GRANHOLM's desk before the November elections.
In the meantime, legislation that would return the state's two giant electric utilities, Detroit Edison and Consumers Energy, to monopoly status is in limbo. A breakthrough on the legislation (HB 5524) isn't expected. Instead, the process seems to be one where drafts of the measure will repeatedly be offered, rewritten and offered again.
(full article)
Mich. power: Institute renewable power rule; stand back from big utilities
(Lansing State Journal, February 11, 2008)
Gird yourself, Michigan - the push is on for big energy reform. The promises are flying, the details are dizzying, the lobbyists are scurrying.
Amid the chaos, it's best to focus on a few key points, such as:
Michigan needs a renewable portfolio standard, or RPS, to propel utilities to acquire power from renewable sources.
Michigan will benefit from investments in alternative energy research and development. (full article)
Michigan has huge energy potential
(Lansing State Journal, February 15, 2008)
How does renewable energy affect Michigan's future? Renewable energy can be found in sources such as solar, wind, corn, and waste products. Michigan has an abundance of all these.
Solar power has been around for more than 100 years, but because of the abundance of fossil fuels, it was not taken seriously enough until the oil shortages of the 1970s. Electricity can be generated using photo voltaic cells. A portion of this research is being done at Hemlock Semiconductor in central Michigan. The prices for these cells have declined an average 4 percent over the last 15 years. (full article)
DTE moving ahead with Fermi 3 plan
(Monroe Evening News, February 17, 2008)
Though Michigan's economy is sputtering, DTE Energy is continuing to plan for a new nuclear power plant near its existing Fermi 2 reactor near Newport, encouraged by federal energy policy and persuaded that electricity demand will grow.
"We are still on target to submit an application by the end of this year," said John J. Austerberry, a DTE spokesman. "Work is continuing to prepare the application, but we cannot commit to moving ahead until the regulatory issues are addressed at the state." (full article)
Attorney general, governor disagree on future of Public Act 141
(Bay City Times, February 18, 2008)
State Attorney General Mike Cox said the state should not repeal a law that would take away consumer
choice to pick their utility power provider.
But Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm said she backs altering the rules, known as Public Act 141, although without
an outright ban on competition. (full article)
ABATE Puts Energy Bills Cost At $2.7B
(MIRS, February 21, 2008)
Evolving legislation that further waters down Michigan's electric choice plan would cost Michigan ratepayers $2.7 billion a year, a 39 percent overall rate increase for Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison customers, according to information the legislation's opponents are shopping around Lansing.
The Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity (ABATE), a trade organization for large industrial electric customers, claims that the new power plant construction called for in the House's latest working proposal, combined with the cost of implementing proposed renewable portfolio standards (RPS) will stick customers with $18 billion in capital costs. (full article)
Power hangs in the balance
(Saginaw News, February 21, 2008)
BACK, BRIEFLY, TO PUBLIC Act 141. That's the law that allows customers to pick the power provider they
want.
It's called competition. It's also the law that Consumers Energy and DTE Energy want to repeal so they
have a monopoly on the electricity business. Consumers, in particular, says it needs a guaranteed customer base before it can build a $2 billion, 800-megawatt coal-fired plant next to its Karn-Weadock complex at the mouth of the Saginaw River. (full article)
Energy bills must pass checkpoint
(Detroit Free Press, February 24, 2008)
State Sen. Bruce Patterson, R-Canton, has a carefully cultivated image as an irascible, cantankerous,
bombastic bear of a committee chairman in Lansing. An imposing 6 feet 5, with a twirly white mustache and
stubble, Patterson only concedes with a slight smile that he's not as fearsome in everyday life as when he's grilling a hapless witness at a hearing.
He's in his glory these days, with a pile of controversial energy legislation that must pass through his
checkpoint if it's to get to Gov. Jennifer Granholm's desk. (full article)
Renewable energy represents one of the fastest growing sectors in today's economy... (Letter to the Editor)
(Crain's Detroit Business, February 25, 2008)
Renewable energy represents one of the fastest growing sectors in today's economy, for good reason. Unfortunately, Michigan is getting left behind because we don't have a renewable-energy standard, which is vital to generating clean energy, attracting investments and creating jobs in Michigan.
Unfortunately, a recent article ("DTE, CMS set to spend $6B: Investment key to alt-energy industry in state," crainsdetroit.com, Feb. 5) sends the wrong message. (full article)
More Staff Needed For P.A. 141 Rewrite
(MIRS, February 26, 2008)
Rep. Mike Nofs (R-Battle Creek) asked the Department of Labor and Economic Growth (DLEG) if it had the money to hire up to 25 new Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) employees to implement the changes he's calling for in his electric choice reform bill.
Nofs' P.A. 141 reform bill (HB 5524), which is currently pending in the House, would require the new employees to evaluate rate hikes proposed by Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison (DTE). (full article)
Gov: Michigan In 'Backwater' On RPS
(MIRS, February 26, 2008)
Fresh from the National Governors Association (NGA) conference, an energetic Gov. Jennifer Granholm told reporters Michigan is in the "backwater" of the alternative energy race.
The highly competitive governor said 28 to 30 other states are ahead of Michigan in passing a Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) and unless she and the Legislature move quickly, she said she fears Michigan will lose out, not only on energy savings and conservation, but also on new jobs. (full article)
Energy strategy wanted, and soon
(Detroit Free Press, February 27, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm said Tuesday that Michigan is "a backwater" in promoting renewable energy such as wind power, and called on lawmakers to quickly approve legislation requiring the state to generate 10% of its electric power from renewable sources by 2015.
Granholm said she is encouraged that the House and Senate could reach agreement on the mandate -- called a renewable portfolio standard, or RPS -- by next month. (full article) Gov: Mich. is behind in green jobs race
(Detroit News, February 27, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm has returned from a summit with the nation's governors saying she's convinced Michigan is in the "backwater" of renewable energy and must pass a law by next month requiring the state to meet some of its electricity needs with wind power and other green sources.
She said the state will lose out on wind turbine manufacturing plants and other job-creating ventures without the law, which would mandate that the state generate 10 percent of its electric power from renewable sources by 2015. The state gets 3.5 percent of its electricity from these alternative power sources. (full article)
Granholm: Jobs lost without energy law
(Lansing State Journal, February 27, 2008)
Michigan is losing jobs every day that it fails to pass a law requiring that some of the state's electricity come from wind and renewable sources, Gov. Jennifer Granholm said Tuesday.
"We need to get this done and get it done now," the Democratic governor told reporters. "The urgency of this cannot be overstated." (full article)
Back to Top January 2008
Will Energy Package Split?
(MIRS, January 9, 2008)
One of the things legislative observers will be watching in the early months of the 2008 House session is whether or not the tie-bars on the energy package will hold up.
Recall that the various alternative energy bills are currently tie-barred to HB 5524, legislation that would basically do away with Michigan's Electric Choice Act, which was designed to create competition in the electric utility market.
(full article)
Democrats' energy plans will hurt state
(Crain's Detroit Business, January 14, 2008)
In medicine, the first rule is "do no harm." It covers instances when being half-right can be all wrong, when a diagnosis is correct but the prescribed remedy may kill the patient.
Gov. Jennifer Granholm and House Speaker Andy Dillon are making that mistake regarding Michigan's electricity industry. The proposals they've unveiled have the potential to do real long-term harm to our energy future.
(full article)
Patterson: Energy Package To Move By March
(MIRS, January 17, 2008)
The long-delayed alternative energy package pending in the Legislature may move out of a Senate committee by March, but the committee's chair expressed his frustration today in taking on issues that are "so complicated, so difficult."
"What's the reward?" asked Senate Energy Policy and Public Utilities Committee Chair Bruce PATTERSON (R-Canton) on passing the legislation by his goal of March. "Do we get a bonus? Do we win re-election to the Senate? Not!" (full article)
Tax breaks would spur cleaner coal plants, backers say
(Detroit Free Press, January 22, 2008)
A bi-partisan plan to give tax breaks and other incentives to coal gasification plants would spur construction of
much-needed, clean-burning electric plants in Michigan, its backers said today.
But a coalition of House Democrats and environmental groups called for state laws to prohibit utility companies from charging their customers the cost of new coal plants, and require the utilities’ shareholders to bear the expenses.
(full article)
Barcia leads push for clean-energy bills in Lansing
(Bay City Times, January 22, 2008)
Power companies would be encouraged to use cutting-edge clean energy technology under legislation to be unveiled today in Lansing.
Sen. Jim Barcia, D-Bay City, was set to help introduce the package of bills, designed to simplify the regulatory process and provide technical support for the development of new clean energy facilities, including integrated gasification combined cycle, or IGCC. (full article)
Lawmakers push for green energy
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, January 22, 2008)
State lawmakers are intensifying efforts to require utilities to use a certain percentage of green energy to keep the lights on.
Proponents of the so-called Renewable Portfolio Standard say it not only would lessen the toll on the
environment, but significantly improve Michigan's chances of attracting jobs in the renewable energy field.
(full article)
Alternate Energy Bills Move
(MIRS, January 23, 2008)
The House Energy and Technology Committee reported out three alternative energy bills this evening (HB 5525, HB 5548, and HB 5549) to help set the table for next week's State of the State Address by Gov. Jennifer Granholm.
Granholm is expected to feature alternative energy as an economic stimulus in her address, and now she'll be able to say some legislation along those lines has moved in the Democratic-controlled House. Last week, MIRS reported at least one of the alternative energy bills would move to the House floor to accommodate the Governor's speech (See "Alternative Energy Measure Likely To Move," 01/17/08).
(full article)
“Stop the Monopoly” campaign fighting legislative effort to decrease competition and increase Michigan 's electric rates - CCC Press Release
(January 24, 2008)
Supporters of competition in the Michigan electric system have taken the fight to lawmakers’ front door with a billboard at the state Capitol letting lawmakers know Michigan is watching.
The billboard asks viewers to contact lawmakers and tell them “Don’t turn back the clock on electric competition.” For more information and to reach lawmakers, people can go to www.StopTheMonopoly.com, which will take visitors to the Customer Choice Coalition’s Web site. (full press release)
 
Gov. Granholm plan a virtual tax increase to benefit Consumers, DTE -
CCC Press Release
(January 29, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm today announced her intent to raise electric bills for Michigan families and businesses to support plans by Consumers Energy and DTE to build $6 billion in new electric generation, with minimal regulatory control by the Michigan Public Service Commission.
The governor said she embraced the two utilities plans as a way to increase electric production in Michigan, particularly renewable energy. However, she skipped telling Michigan families that they – not utility shareholders – would be financing the plants, and that customers – not utility shareholders – would be on the hook for cost overruns. The governor also overlooked the fact that the states with the most renewable power are those that give customers the most choice – not force them to buy from monopolies.
(full release)
Tonight's $6 Billion Question
(MIRS, January 29, 2008)
Gov. Jennifer Granholm's State of the State Address tonight made alternative energy a prominent feature in the state's economic future, but her proposals left one large question looming: What will be required to secure a $6 billion in pledged investment from the state's two largest utilities?
Michigan is naturally suited to becoming the North American home of the alternative energy industry, Granholm said, from the state's wind potential to the very power of the Great Lakes' currents. From Michigan's skilled workforce and available factory space to use of the Great Lakes as an excellent way to transport massive wind turbine engines and blades — Granholm sees this nascent industry as the means to replace Michigan lost manufacturing jobs. (full article)
Utility Investment Still Needs Some Legislative Work
(Gongwer News Service, January 29, 2008)
Consumers Energy and Detroit Edison together would invest $6 billion in new generation, but only if the Legislature passes the mandatory 10 percent renewable standard Governor Jennifer Granholm proposed in her State of the State Address on Tuesday. But it is still not clear that mandate will reach her desk.
Ms. Granholm had asserted Consumers and Edison had committed to the investment, and the related 17,000 jobs, and had called on the Legislature to move both the renewable portfolio standard and another restructuring of the state's electric market. (full article)
Gov. pushes job-creating programs
(Detroit News, January 30, 2008)
Two job-creation initiatives totaling nearly a half-billion dollars were announced by Gov. Jennifer Granholm in her State of the State address Tuesday as part of her plan to pump life into Michigan's flagging economy.
The governor called for using $300 million in state employee pension funds to invest over the next three years in young, high-growth companies looking to build and create jobs in Michigan, which leads the nation in unemployment. (full article)
Alternative energy key in Granholm's State of the State address
(Associated Press, January 30, 2008)
Alternative energy was the keystone of Gov. Jennifer Granholm's sixth annual State of the State speech, as she envisioned a future where Michigan's lost manufacturing jobs are replaced by companies providing power from water, wind and wood.
The Democratic governor made the pitch to lawmakers and the public Tuesday night. Michigan has the nation's highest unemployment rate and the third-highest foreclosure rate, and Granholm said she is determined to create more jobs. (full article)
Coalition: Choice Will Make Renewables Cheaper
(MIRS, January 31, 2008)
A group aimed at keeping Michigan's utility deregulation intact presented its vision for alternative energy to the Senate Energy Policy Committee today. Former Michigan Public Service Commission Chair Eric SCHNEIDEWIND testified on behalf of the Customer Choice Coalition (CCC), which includes several utilities, the Small Business Association of Michigan, Big Three and Michigan Association of School Boards. (full article)
House Energy Plan to Move By March
(Gongwer News Service, January 31, 2008)
Though the utilities and their competitors appear still miles apart on how to address the state's energy needs, some plan will be moving from the House by the end of February.
A workgroup of leaders from both chambers, the administration, utilities and their competitors met for some four hours Wednesday night to begin hashing out a final package. (full article)
Dillon: Energy Package Priority One
(MIRS, January 31, 2008)
House Speaker Andy DILLON (D-Redford Twp.) said today passage of a bi-partisan alternative energy package that includes reforms to the state's electric choice law is his top legislative priority going into the 2008 end of the current legislative session.
The House Speaker said adopting renewable portfolio standards and other pieces of legislation to encourage alternative energy production is linked with making changes to P.A. 141 and he's working with House Energy and Tech Committee Chair Frank ACCAVITTI Jr. (D-Eastpointe) and Rep. Mike NOFS (R-Battle Creek) on what those changes will be. (full article)
Back To Top 2007 News Archives
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
August 2007
October 2007
November 2007
December 2007
January 2007
Statewide Energy Plan Projects Savings But Not Costs
(MIRS, January 31, 2007)
Michigan Public Service Commission Chairman J. Peter LARK today released his overdue statewide 21st Century Energy Plan, telling reporters it would save electric customers at least $4 billion over the next 20 years.
However, he couldn't put a price tag on the cost of the plan, which calls for more alternative energy production in the short term, a new coal-fired plant down the road and a look into nuclear energy even further down the road.
The 40-page plan recommends that Michigan's future needs be met through a combination of renewable resources and the cleanest generating technology coupled with energy savings achieved through increased energy efficiency. (full article)
State report: Michigan needs new power plant
(Detroit News, January 31, 2007)
Michigan needs a major new power plant by 2015 to handle increased electricity demands, according to a report today to the governor on the state's future energy needs. (full article)
House hearings could begin shortly on energy plan
(Gongwer News Service, January 31, 2007)
The House Energy and Technology Committee will begin discussing Public Service Commission Chair Peter Lark's new energy plan for the state in the coming weeks, but it could be many weeks longer before any action is taken, said committee Chair Rep. Frank Accavitti (D-Eastpointe). (full article)
Back To Top Is Michigan 's energy plan for open markets, or against them?
(Restructuring Today, February 1, 2007)
The Michigan PSC yesterday released the state's first comprehensive energy plan since its markets opened Jan 1, 2002.
The plan seeks efficiency, more renewable energy and added generation.
The Consumer Choice Coalition -- a group of marketers, residential customers and businesses -- responded quickly, saying the plan would effectively kill competition and ensure Michigan has the highest power prices in the Midwest for years to come. (full article)
Electric Competition Down
(MIRS, February 1, 2007)
In its annual report, the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) announced that electric competition in the state is down 51 percent, marking the second straight year of decline.
The report showed that 7,300 commercial and industrial customers participated in Michigan's electric customer choice, a decrease of approximately 51 percent from the previous year. (full article)
DTE Wants MPSC To Set Rate
(MIRS, February 1, 2007)
DTE Energy wants the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to set its distribution rates as a way to help lower rates for low-income citizens, support conservation efforts and rein in its increasing costs, the Senate Technology and Energy Committee learned today.
DTE wants its delivery rate to undergo what's referred to as "revenue decoupling." Seventy-seven percent of a customers' energy bill is the cost of the fuel itself. Energy companies must charge customers exactly what they pay for energy. (full article)
State unveils energy plan
(Detroit Free Press, February 1, 2007)
Michigan Public Service Commission Chairman Peter Lark unveiled the state's long-awaited comprehensive
energy plan Wednesday, calling for 10% of Michigan's energy to be produced by renewable sources by 2015.
The 21st Century Energy plan, which was commissioned by Gov. Jennifer Granholm last April, also calls for
giving consideration to building at least one coal-fired power plant and adopting energy efficiency standards over the next eight years.
The creation of a Michigan Energy Efficiency Program could cost the average residential customer about 50
cents more a month, or about $6 more a year, to pay for energy education around the state. (full article)
State must act to meet energy needs
(Booth Newspapers, February 1, 2007)
Michigan will need a new coal-fired power plant, hundreds of wind generators and
unprecedented conservation efforts to meet the state's future energy needs, a Granholm administration report finds.
Doing nothing to address those needs would cost Michigan consumers $4 billion more over the next two decades to purchase power on an open market that's only going up in price, said Peter Lark, Michigan Public Service Commission chairman.
"Michigan is going to need more power going forward in the 21st century," Lark said Wednesday, during the unveiling of the PSC-compiled report. "We're going to have to buy more and more power at higher and higher prices." (full article)
Report offers starting point for energy plan (Editorial)
(Detroit News, February 1, 2007)
Michigan's electricity problems are well founded and not likely to be solved by any one mandate or technology. That's why it was good to see a range of options presented in a report released Wednesday addressing the state's long-term energy needs.
Of particular interest and promise was the urging by J. Peter Lark, chairman of the Michigan Public Service
Commission, to build a major new power plant powered by clean-coal technology. Of all the points presented in the plan, this is the most critical.
Getting there, however, will be a challenge. (full article)
Power points: Besides new generating plant, state's planning for electricity will need to control high costs (Editorial)
(Grand Rapids Press, February 4, 2007)
Even in Michigan's dimly lit economy of 2007, electric power needs are growing. Unless the state is going to buy that power elsewhere -- at a cost both in dollars and reliability -- plans must be made now to generate more electricity.
That message in a report issued last week by the Michigan Public Service Commission ought to get attention in the state. The Legislature, for sure, needs to read the report and react. There will be a price for doing nothing. The PSC puts that number at $4 billion by 2020: what Michigan would have to pay to Canada and to other states in the Midwest for electric power to meet demand here. Some of that power-shopping already is occurring, mostly to meet peak demand in summers. (full article)
DTE moves ahead with nuclear plant
(Monroe Evening News, February 13, 2007)
A new nuclear power plant that could cost $3 billion might sprout within the decade next to DTE Energy's existing Fermi 2 plant, the utility's chief said Monday.
"Today I am pleased to announce that DTE Energy has started work on preparing a license application for a new nuclear plant at our existing Fermi site near Monroe," said Anthony F. Earley Jr., DTE chairman and chief executive officer, during a speech at the Detroit Economic Club.
"This is the first step to providing clean, reliable and affordable energy for the better part of the rest of this century. And with it, we will provide thousands of highly paid jobs to highly skilled Michigan workers." (full article) Michigan gets a D in deregulation report
(Detroit Free Press, February 12, 2007)
Michigan received a grade of D in a recent report on electric deregulation and the creation of an inviting environment for small- and medium-size businesses looking for a variety of choices in purchasing electric power.
Liberty Power Corp.’s 2007 Electric Choice Report Card gave Michigan that grade, in large part, because the
state’s current regulatory environment makes it difficult for small businesses to shop around for the best possible price for electricity.
Electricity costs are among the biggest concerns for small- and medium-size business owners. (full article) State energy plan: Progress or regress? (Editorial)
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, February 18, 2007)
The Michigan 21st Century Energy Plan, presented last month by Public Service Commission Chairman J. Peter Lark, is a good first step toward setting the state's energy policy for the future. It calls for building new power plants, conserving energy and using renewal resources for power.
We would add one more goal -- to rethink whether deregulation of utilities is working.
Lark's report has gotten mixed reviews so far. Utilities see much good in it but they have their own ideas to add. Environmentalists call it a mere baby step toward energy efficiency. (full article)
Choice Coalition Counters Energy Plan
(Gongwer News Service, February 27, 2007)
Public Service Commission Chair Peter Lark, when he was an assistant attorney general, was a fixture at press conferences hosted by members of the Customer Choice Coalition. Now he, or at least his energy plan, is the target of disparaging remarks from that coalition as the group fears his plan would mean an end to choice programs. The coalition sponsored a luncheon Tuesday hoping to convince legislators that, while Mr. Lark's projections on energy need cannot be disputed, his proposals for finding that power can. (full article)
Study: Public Acts Lowered Utility Rates
(MIRS, February 27, 2007)
A new report released today by the Customer Choice Coalition (CCC) shows that customers, utilities and developers have seen increased reliability and lowered electric costs since the government enacted two public acts.
Public Acts 141 and 142 of 2000 are addressing the needs of customers, utilities and non-utility competitive generators who wanted to build generating plants in Michigan, claims the report for the group that advocates for alternative energy suppliers. (full article)
DTE CFO expects return to full regulation
(Megawatt Daily, February 28, 2007)
A DTE Energy executive Tuesday predicted Michigan’s “hybrid” electric restructuring model will be scrapped by legislators, with the state’s electric utility industry returning to a “full regulated environment.”
Re-regulation will allow utilities to invest in new baseload generation needed in the state, said David Meador, DTE executive vice president and CFO. (full article)
Back To Top March 2007
Michigan group defends restructuring law
(Megawatt Daily, March 1, 2007)
While utilities are advocating repeal or significant changes to Michigan’s retail choice law, a customer choice group released a report late Tuesday saying consumers have saved millions of dollars as a result of the restructured market.
“The evidence is clear – competition and choice work. Policymakers should be encouraged to increase competition to meet Michigan’s future electric needs,” said Barry Cargill, executive director of the Customer Choice Coalition. The group is a collection of merchant generators and large and small industrial customers, formed a few years ago when Detroit Edison parent DTE Energy started pushing for changes in the restructuring law. (full article)
Competition remains cloaked in anonymity
(Saginaw News, March 5, 2007)
Twenty million bathtubs won't stand in the way of 500 new jobs at Hemlock Semiconductor Corp.
A $50 million electricity bill might, though.
Mid-Michigan leaders are hoping Consumers Energy doesn't short circuit the Thomas Township plant's loyalty to its home of 40 years as Semiconductor officials ponder taking a $600 million to $1.2 billion expansion plan elsewhere. (full article) Those controlling the electricity have the power (Opinion Editorial)
(Saginaw News, March 25, 2007)
Hats off to The Saginaw News for exploring in depth the problems facing Michigan manufacturers -- in this
case, Hemlock Semiconductor -- when it comes to getting competitive electricity rates.
Many manufacturers pay more in electric bills than they do in tax bills. And while the state has been cutting
the Single Business Tax over the last decade, moving Michigan closer to the regional average, our state's
electricity rates have been increasing, and are the highest in the Midwest for manufacturers. (full article)
Electric-powered savings (Editorial)
(Grand Rapids Press, March 25, 2007)
Even in Michigan's dim-bulb economy, electricity needs are growing enough to plan an expansion of power
supplies. But lawmakers and the Public Service Commission should take care that any such changes don't
pull the plug on independent power suppliers.
The independents -- gas-fired, renewable and other alternatives to utility giants Consumers Energy and
Detroit Edison -- are essential to maintaining competition and a free market for energy, keys to lowering
electricity costs. The state's rates are above regional averages, especially for industrial customers.
Michigan's industrial rates top those of Illinois, Indiana, Ohio and Wisconsin. (full article)
Dillon Plan Touches Utilities, Graduated Income Tax
(MIRS, March 28, 2007)
House Speaker Andy DILLON (D-Redford Twp.) is considering a plan under which the state would tap utilities for additional revenues in return for giving the utilities back their monopoly status. In addition, MIRS has learned that House Democrats are considering a move to put a graduated income tax on the statewide ballot in 2008. Ending townships is another piece being considered.
The utility plan would be a deal under which the state would increase taxes on utilities in exchange for rescinding, or significantly changing PA 141, a law that provides for more competition in the state's energy market. (full article)
Dillon Proposed Utility Tax, Says Other Plans on the Way
(Gongwer News Service, March 29, 2007)
House Speaker Andy Dillon (D-Redford Twp.) is putting together a tax proposal for the state's utilities that is expected to generate $500 million over a year. But while the leader said Thursday that tax would be structured so consumers wouldn't bear the entire burden of higher utility bills, he shied away from divulging the specifics of that plan along with what other cuts and reforms he has up his sleeve.
Mr. Dillon opened up his well-attended press conference by saying House committees would be meeting over what was supposed to be their spring break to review what reforms can be made to government in their particular specialties and that he intended to release further details of his plan next week. (full article)
Business Wants Details on Dillon Plan, Leery of Repealing Choice
(Gongwer News Service, March 29, 2007)
Business organizations said they wanted more details before taking a stand on House Speaker Andy Dillon's (D-Redford Twp.) proposal to generate new revenues by taxing utilities. Some were also concerned that the proposal to repeal the customer choice act (PA 141, 2000) would hurt consumers.
One official blasted the proposal as creating a new monopoly for the state's largest utilities, and hoped that Mr. Dillon would reconsider the proposal. (full article)
Cox To Speaker: 'Forget It'
(MIRS, March 29, 2007)
Today Attorney General Mike COX responded strongly to news of the plan to increase revenues by levying higher taxes on the state's top two utilities (DTE and Consumers Energy) in exchange for giving them back their monopoly status.
House Speaker Andy DILLON (D-Redford Twp.) had floated the plan behind the scenes until yesterday, but details burst into the headlines of the most recent editions of MIRS and the Detroit Free Press. By this morning it had become "the issue" of the day around the Capitol. (full article)
House speaker: Utility tax could generate $500M for state
(Crain's Detroit Business, March 29, 2007)
House Speaker Andy Dillon said Thursday that a utility tax that might generate around $500 million is part of a comprehensive budget solution being developed by House Democrats.
Dillon, D-Redford Township, also told Crain’s he is “shooting for” a complete elimination of Michigan’s personal-property tax in the Democrats’ plan, details of which he said would be unveiled next week. (full article)
Dump new tax schemes in favor of real reforms (Editorial)
(Detroit News, March 30, 2007)
Michigan residents are clear that they don't support tax increases to fix the state's budget deficit. But for
some reason that hasn't sunk in with some state Democrats, including House Speaker Andy Dillon and Gov.
Jennifer Granholm.
Dillon, D-Redford Township, said Thursday he is working on a plan to shave about $500 million of the state's $940 million budget shortfall by fundamentally changing the state's utility market. Two major components of the plan, which Dillon says is still being drafted, include taxing utility companies and eliminating the competitive market that now exists. (full article)
Dump new tax schemes in favor of real reforms (Editorial)
(Detroit News, March 30, 2007)
Michigan residents are clear that they don't support tax increases to fix the state's budget deficit. But for
some reason that hasn't sunk in with some state Democrats, including House Speaker Andy Dillon and Gov.
Jennifer Granholm.
Dillon, D-Redford Township, said Thursday he is working on a plan to shave about $500 million of the state's $940 million budget shortfall by fundamentally changing the state's utility market. Two major components of the plan, which Dillon says is still being drafted, include taxing utility companies and eliminating the competitive market that now exists. (full article)
Utility tax electrifies opposition
(Detroit Free Press, March 30, 2007)
House Democrats' plan for a new tax on utility companies that would net $500 million to help balance the state budget stirred the political pot Thursday, as Republican reaction ranged from wariness to outrage.
House Speaker Andy Dillon, D-Redford Township, said his plan would not allow utilities to pass on the entire cost of the tax to their customers. He said details were incomplete as he announced plans for House committees to meet during the usual spring break next week to finish a budget by the end of April. (full article)
Back To Top April 2007
Making the big bets
(Crain's Detroit Business, April 1, 2007)
House Speaker Andy Dillon likes to think big.
He's looking at ways to set up a statewide catastrophic health care fund to help businesses control their health care costs, and he's eyeing a utility tax, potentially coupled with repeal of Michigan's electric-choice law. (full article)
Big Three Unhappy With Lark Plan
(MIRS, April 2, 2007)
The financially beleaguered Big Three automakers are privately circulating a document purporting to show a $153 million increase in energy costs under a plan written by the chair of the Public Service Commission (MPSC).
General Motors, Chrysler, Ford, U.S. Steel, Delphi, Marathon Petroleum and Martin Marietta are among 17 major industries opposing the 21st Century Energy Plan embraced by MPSC Chair Peter LARK. (full article)
Utility tax a bad idea (Editorial)
(Saginaw News, April 3, 2007)
Democratic House Speaker Andy Dillion pitched a half-baked idea last week to tax the state's big electric utilities that he said would raise about $500 million a year.
It's a bad idea. The last thing Michigan needs is higher electricity rates, which would drive more employers to states with lower energy costs and taxes. (full article)
Efforts to re-regulate utilities may harm credit
(Platt's MegaWatt Daily, April 4, 2006)
Current political efforts to return electric utilities to 1980s style cost-of-service "regulation is a risky proposition that could threaten utility balance sheets, destroy value and impair credit ratings," Standard & Poor's said Tuesday.
S&P, like Platts, is a division of The McGraw-Hill Companies. (full article)
Competitors: Deregulation Tied to Securitization
(Gongwer News Service, April 4, 2007)
If the state repeals PA 141, 2000 and re-regulates the electric market in the state, it must also find a way to take back the securitization it provided the utilities, competitors and industrial users told the House Energy and Technology Committee at continuing hearings on the issue Tuesday. (full article) Joos Calls for Re-regulation of Utilities
(Gongwer News Service, April 5, 2007)
Electric choice has succeeded only in preventing development of new electric generation in the state and has not provided the power cost savings anticipated, Consumers Energy CEO David Joos told the House Energy and Technology Committee on Thursday as part of its ongoing hearings on the possible repeal of PA 141, 2000. (full article) Changes to Customer Choice Coming
(Gongwer News Service, April 10, 2007)
Provisions allowing electric customers in the state to choose a competitor instead of the local utility may not go away, but they will have to change to ensure the state has enough power, House Energy and Technology Committee Chair Rep. Frank Accavitti (D-Eastpointe) told Gongwer News Service on Tuesday. (full article)
Law makers debate energy law for major power plants
(Detroit News, April 11, 2007)
The head of DTE Energy told lawmakers today that the state should repeal a seven-year-old law that he said has failed to bring competition and lower prices into the energy market and stands in the way of much-needed construction for major power plants. (full article)
DTE: Let's Get Rid Of P.A. 141
(MIRS, April 11, 2007)
DTE Energy Chairman and CEO Anthony EARLEY told a House panel this morning that the electrical regulatory structure created in 2000 to spur industry competition has become an "unworkable hybrid structure" that has stunted construction of any in-state power plant. (full article)
DTE's Earley Says Customer Choice Meant to be "Transitional"
(Gongwer News Service, April 11, 2007)
When DTE Energy signed off on what became PA 141, 2000, officials said at the time that the structure of customer choice was meant to be transitional and one that should be reviewed to address long-term goals, Chair and CEO Tony Earley told members of the House Energy and Technology on Wednesday. Saying later that he believed the "forces and the issues are right to do it," Mr. Earley told reporters he was asking legislators to take bold leadership in repealing the statute and addressing the state's long-term electric energy needs. (full article)
DTE Energy chief to testify about utility regulations
(Detroit Free Press, April 11, 2007)
DTE Energy Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Anthony Earley Jr. will testified before the Michigan House
of Representative’s Energy & Technology Committee Wednesday morning about changes to the state’s utility regulatory environment. (full article)
Earley favors utility changes
(Detroit Free Press, April 12, 2007)
The state's current utility regulatory environment must change, DTE Energy Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Anthony Earley Jr. testified Wednesday before the Michigan House of Representatives Energy and Technology Committee.
Specifically, Earley said certain parts of Public Act 141 should be changed and a monopoly-structured system should be adopted. (full article)
PIRGIM Report Backs P.A. 141 Repeal
(MIRS, April 12, 2007)
Michigan residents have not benefited from the state's electric choice experiment. Rather, it has thrown electric costs for large corporations and small residential ratepayers alike under a cloud of unpredictability and put the state's ability to generate enough electricity in the long-term at risk according to a report released by a consumer advocacy group this week. (full article)
Dow Corning is a needed success story
(Detroit Free Press, April 17, 2007)
To those who would despair at Michigan's poor performance in the latest Best Places for Business rankings in the April 23 issue of Forbes magazine, be my guest.
Michigan takes only one spot in the top 75 among Forbes' top 200 major metro areas (Ann Arbor at 74th), yet we claim seven of the bottom 75 places in the ranking, with Flint (192) and Detroit (198) landing in the bottom 10.
(full article)
Accavitti: P.A. 141 Changes Needed
(MIRS, April 19, 2007)
Key lawmakers said today that Michigan's electric choice law has benefited some of the state's largest electric users, but has done nothing to lower rates for residential customers and needs to be changed.
House Energy and Technology Committee Chair Frank ACCAVITTI (D-Eastpointe) said today he doesn't envision a total repeal of P.A. 141 during this legislative session. But he said some changes do need to be made and not in the direction of increased deregulation, which has "failed horribly" in states such as California. (full article)
CMS Energy ready to reposition itself in changing market
(Jackson Citizen Patriot, April 29, 2007)
Having survived a global expansion that went bust and an energy-trading scandal that torpedoed its reputation, CMS Energy is planning a power play to reposition itself as a premier U.S. utility.
The Jackson-based utility has shed the majority of its overseas assets -- about $1.4 billion in total -- and plans to use those funds to focus on what it does best: produce and sell energy to Michigan residents and businesses. (full article)
Consumers Energy plans 2 new plants, more efficiency
(Crain's Detroit Business, April 30, 2007)
Consumers Energy Co. is laying out a 20-year energy plan that includes a potential $1.5 billion to $2.5 billion investment in new plants and increased use of renewable energy, greater energy efficiency and controlling electricity demand.
The plan, called the balanced energy initiative, is scheduled to be filed with the Michigan Public Service Commission this week and is the Jackson-based utility’s blueprint to meet a growing need for electricity. (full article)
Back To Top May 2007 Legislation aims to give residents choice of electricity
(Associated Press, May 8, 2007)
Legislation outlined Tuesday aims to give Michigan residents more than one option when buying their electricity, though achieving true residential choice will be tough.
Bills sponsored by Republican senators would eliminate what they call "double billing," where customers
who leave the state's regulated utilities for alternative electric suppliers pay twice for administrative costs
such as billing and collection. (full article)
Legislators, Corporate Execs Say Electric Competition Critical
(Gongwer News Service, May 8, 2007)
Maintaining Michigan's current electric competition structure is critical to the state's economy and several Senate members said on Tuesday that they have introduced legislation expanding that competition component so that residential customers can take advantage of it. (full article)
Senate Bills Counter Dillon Energy Plan
(MIRS, May 8, 2007)
Senate Republicans introduced three bills today that counter House Speaker Andy DILLON's (D-Redford Twp.) plan to repeal the state's eletric choice law, P.A. 141, and return the energy market back to the energy monopolies. Rather, the package is designed to make it more enticing for private companies to invest in new power plants. (full article) Legislation for Electricity Provider Competition
(WLNS TV, May 9, 2007)
You might have a shot at someday picking your own electricity provider. Legislation outlined aims to give Michigan residents more than one option when buying electricity, but achieving true residential choice will be much tougher. A 2000 state law that deregulated the electricity market lets customers choose their power provider, but so far suppliers have only competed for their business customers.
Legislation aims to give residents choice of electricity
(WOOD TV, May 9, 2007)
Legislation outlined Tuesday aims to give Michigan residents more than one option when buying their electricity, though achieving true residential choice will be tough.
Bills sponsored by Republican senators would eliminate what they call "double billing," where customers who leave the state's regulated utilities for alternative electric suppliers pay twice for administrative costs such as billing and collection. (full article)
Legislation targets electricity options
(WKAR, May 9, 2007)
New legislation aims to give Michigan residents more than one option when buying their electricity, though achieving true residential choice will be tough. Michigan's 2000 law that deregulated the electricity market lets customers choose their power provider, though so far alternative suppliers have competed only for business customers and NOT residents. (full article)
Just who's criticizing electric deregulation - Editorial
(Oakland Press, May 13, 2007)
The public needs to scrutinize the current wave of claims that electric deregulation has not worked in Michigan. Evidence indicates that it has at least slowed the increase in rates.
And just who are the critics of deregulation? Not surprisingly, they are principally the big utilities - all the more reason for suspicion. Jackson-based CMS Energy Corp.'s chief executive, David Joos, said his company will not build a new power plant unless Michigan lawmakers repeal or revise a 2000 law that lets consumers pick their electricity suppliers. Detroit-based DTE Energy's chairman and chief executive officer, Anthony F. Earley Jr., echoed those sentiments.
(full article)
Back To Top August 2007
Boost utility competition - Editorial
(Saginaw News, August 28, 2007)
Power is showing lots of promise nowadays.
In Rogers City, there's the Wolverine Power Supply Co-op. In Alma, there's the Great Lakes Energy Research Park. Up in Ubly there's a wind turbine project. Closer to home, in Midland there's Mid-Michigan Energy, a $1.3 billion facility that could start up in 2013 to sell electricity on the open market.
These are all private operations, taking advantage of an energy-choice law -- Act 141 -- passed seven years ago that opened Michigan's energy markets to more competition. (full article) Isiogu To Lead P.S.C
(Gongwer News Service, August 29, 2007)
Orjiakor Isiogu, chief of the Public Service Commission's Telecommunications Division was Wednesday appointed as chair of the commission.
Governor Jennifer Granholm announced Wednesday that Mr. Isiogu succeeds former commissioner, and one-time chair, Laura Chappelle. Mr. Isiogu was also appointed chair of the commission, as was expected for the final appointee to the three-member commission. (full article)
Back To Top October 2007
Consumers Energy plant costs up 42 percent in five months - CCC Press Release
(October 3, 2007)
Consumers Energy proposed new plant has a 42 percent cost overrun before it’s even started, showing the danger of returning control of Michigan’s electric system to monopoly utilities and the need for creation of fair, open competitive bidding process to meet Michigan’s future electric needs.
Consumers Energy has told the Michigan Public Service Commission that its planned coal-fired plant near Bay City will cost $1.44 billion – up from $1.15 billion it estimated in May. The utility notified the commission of the increase in the cost of the proposed plant in a filing on Sept. 21. The revised filing states, "The cost of construction anticipated by this estimate is approximately 42% higher than the…estimate used in the original (May 1, 2007) filing. (full release)
Back To Top November 2007
Report Says Alternative Energy Could Bring 35,000 Jobs To State
(Gongwer News Service, November 8, 2007)
If Michigan lawmakers can beat other Midwest states in the race to approve renewable energy portfolio standards, it can provide the incentive for alternative energy manufacturers to set up shop in the state, bringing up to 35,000 jobs with them, said a report released on Wednesday from the Blue Green Alliance, a partnership of the United Steelworkers and the Sierra Club.
According to the report, the state is ranked fourth for its job potential, right behind Wisconsin and ahead of Missouri. If it utilized its potential, the state could add 24,350 jobs in wind power, 6,644 in solar power, 1,502 in geothermal power and 2,281 jobs in biomass. (full article)
Former Regulators Seeking Electric Choice
(Gongwer News Service, November 8, 2007)
Former Public Service Commission members Laura Chappelle, Robert Nelson, Ronald Russell and David Svanda have joined 34 of their counterparts from across the nation calling on state and federal lawmakers and regulators not to return monopoly control of power markets to the utilities.
The letter, noting a number of reports showing customers saving money or power using the competitive market, argued customers are learning to take advantage of the markets. "Empowered consumers have an amazing history of driving the American economy - electricity markets are no different," the letter said. "If given a chance, consumers will tell the market what they want and the market will respond." (full article)
Historic proposal puts renewable energy and competition
at forefront of Michigan’s electric solutions - CCC Press Release
(November 8, 2007)
The Customer Choice Coalition today unveiled its plan to use competition and market forces to encourage renewable energy companies to expand in Michigan and meet our state’s future electric needs.
The coalition, which brings together electric users of all sizes and independent power producers, is urging policymakers to compare the long-term total cost of reliable renewable energy supplies to the long-term total cost of a new large base-load coal fired plant as the state addresses need for additional electricity in the near term. (full release)
Former Regulators Seeking Electric Choice
(Gongwer News Service, November 8, 2007)
Former Public Service Commission members Laura Chappelle, Robert Nelson, Ronald Russell and David Svanda have joined 34 of their counterparts from across the nation calling on state and federal lawmakers and regulators not to return monopoly control of power markets to the utilities.
The letter, noting a number of reports showing customers saving money or power using the competitive market, argued customers are learning to take advantage of the markets. "Empowered consumers have an amazing history of driving the American economy - electricity markets are no different," the letter said. "If given a chance, consumers will tell the market what they want and the market will respond." (full article)
Historic proposal puts renewable energy and competition
at forefront of Michigan’s electric solutions - CCC Press Release
(November 8, 2007)
The Customer Choice Coalition today unveiled its plan to use competition and market forces to encourage renewable energy companies to expand in Michigan and meet our state’s future electric needs.
The coalition, which brings together electric users of all sizes and independent power producers, is urging policymakers to compare the long-term total cost of reliable renewable energy supplies to the long-term total cost of a new large base-load coal fired plant as the state addresses need for additional electricity in the near term.
(full release)
Electric Choice Group Pitches Market-Driven Power Plan
(MIRS, November 9, 2007)
The Customer Choice Coalition (CCC) — a group of residential, commercial and industrial power customers and independent power suppliers — on Thursday put their two cents in on where discussion of the state's energy policy should go.
"We believe renewable electricity generators can provide reliable power to Michigan in the near term for less than a new coal-fired plant, particularly when expected federal anti-pollution and carbon reduction plans are put in place," said CCC Executive Director Barry Cargill. (full article)
'Compromise' Bill Changes Up Electric Market Regulation
(Gongwer News Service, November 13, 2007)
Legislation soon to be introduced in the House and taken up by the Energy and Technology Committee will create a one-time window for electric consumers to stick with a choice system, opening up the chance larger utilities will move forward in building a new power plant in the state.
Committee Chair Rep. Frank Accavitti (D-Eastpointe) told Gongwer News Service his re-regulation legislation will be meshed with a proposal by Rep. Mike Nofs (R-Battle Creek) for a window for choice customers as part of a compromise on the issue regarding PA 141. (full article)
Alternative energy could be big job-maker for state
(Battle Creek Enquirer, November 20, 2007)
Alternative energy no longer is just a pipe dream of the environmental movement.
Our nation's dependence on an uncertain supply of foreign oil, concerns about carbon dioxide emissions and other factors gradually are boosting the economic viability of developing energy sources that utilize the sun, wind, water and other means. (full article)
Back To Top December 2007
House energy hearings near
(Crain's Detroit Business, December 3, 2007)
A battle over Michigan’s energy future may be about to heat up in the Capitol.
House Energy & Technology Committee Chair Frank Accavitti, D-Eastpointe, plans to start hearings, possibly this week, on a package of bills that would set new standards for renewable sources of energy and energy efficiency, alter utility-rate structures, establish a new approval process for power plants and other electricity generation, and narrow the Michigan law that lets customers choose alternative-electricity suppliers. (full article) No Return To Energy Monopolies
(MIRS, December 5, 2007)
Earlier this year, DTE and Consumers Energy asked the Legislature to restore its monopoly status and eliminate the consumer choice program now in effect (See "Let's Get Rid Of P.A. 141," 4/11/07).
If the House Energy and Technology Committee chair has his way that is not going to happen under the energy reform legislation his caucus is rolling out in committee this week. (full article)
Lawmakers
(Bay City Times, December 7, 2007)
Building a new coal-fired power plant in Bay County may hinge on the fate of legislation introduced this week in the Michigan House of Representatives.
House Bill 5524 would change the state's current law that regulates electric utilities. A Consumers Energy official said Thursday the company is backing the new legislation. (full article)
Opposition grows to Accavitti plan that would raise electric rates,
kill choice and competition - CCC Press Release
(December 10, 2007)
Opposition is growing to legislation that would take away choice from Michigan’s electric customers and raise rates for residential customers by $350 million.
Groups representing electric customers, including senior citizens, schools and business, along with independent energy companies joined former Michigan Public Service Commission members in expressing strong opposition to House Bills 5520-24, being pushed this week by Rep. Frank Accavitti, D-Eastpointe, who chairs the House Energy and Technology Committee. (full release)
Crain's Detroit Business
(December 10, 2007)
Opposition to State's Plan for Renewable Energy
(WLNS, December 10, 2007)
There's new opposition to legislation at the State Capitol that aims to make our state use more renewable energy. It's a package of bills that's currently before the house energy and technology committee. In a press conference, those against it said the bills would kill electric choices in Michigan and say it would create a monopoly in the state.
(full article)
Battle brewing over Michigan's utility choice law
(Bay City Times, December 10, 2007)
The Tri-City area is poised to become an energy producing powerhouse as plans take shape to build coal-fired plants in Bay and Midland counties.
But a growing political fight over how the state regulates electric utilities could decide if one or both of the plants ever break ground. (full article)
Customers, Competitors urge against House energy package
(Gongwer News Service, December 10, 2007)
A package of bills now before the House Energy and Technology Committee would mean higher electric rates for residents and businesses, a group representing those customers and alternative electric suppliers said Monday.
Members of the Customer Choice Coalition said at a press conference that the package (HB 5520, HB 5521, HB 5522, HB 5523, HB 5524) would allow utilities to set rates as they chose and would not allow competitors an opportunity to offset those increases. (full article)
Choice Coalition Comes Out Swinging
(MIRS, December 10, 2007)
The chair of a committee considering electric industry reforms claims his legislative changes would allow consumers to still pick a utility, but the head of the Customer Choice Coalition (CCC) said today, "This legislation would literally kill electric choice (and) customers would see rates go up immediately." (full article)
Debate starts on energy bills
(Detroit News, December 11, 2007)
The battle begins today over a state energy package that backers say would stabilize Michigan's electricity market into the future, but critics contend it would kill competition and drive up monthly electric bills.
Hearings on the five-bill package are scheduled for today, Wednesday and Thursday in the House Energy and Technology Committee and possible passage to the floor for late this week or next week, said committee Chairman Frank Accavitti Jr., D-Eastpointe. (full article)
Coalition continues fight over electric choice
(WKAR, December 11, 2007)
A coalition of groups that purchase power from smaller Michigan utility companies is continuing to fight legislation that would eliminate the state’s electric choice law.
One member calls it the most consumer-unfriendly legislation he’s seen. (full article) Energy debate will continue after the holidays
(Crain's Detroit Business, December 17, 2007)
Bills that would enact broad changes in Michigan's energy regulation will continue to percolate over the holidays, after seeing an initial committee hearing last week.
As Crain's reported earlier this month, the bills are touching off a major debate over issues such as utility rates, power-plant approval, renewable sources of energy and the future of a Michigan law that lets customers choose alternative-electricity suppliers. (full article)
Electric Choice Not Dead, But Could See Limits
(Gongwer News Service, December 20, 2007)
Electric utilities could see customers continue to move back and forth between regulated and unregulated rates, but how many of those customers could move would be limited under a plan that appears likely to be part of the final House electric restructuring package that will begin moving after January 1. (full article)
Energy Bills Still Have Life
(MIRS, December 20, 2007)
The debate over energy regulation raged on today, even as most legislative business grinded to a halt during the week before Christmas.
On the heels of testimony by supporters of the House's original offering on energy reform (HB 5520, HB 5521, HB 5522, HB 5523, HB 5524 and HB 5525) the House Energy and Technology Committee today listened to members of the Consumer Choice Coalition (CCC) speak against it (See "P.A. 141 Rewrite Staying Put For Now," 12/12/07).
(full article)
Back To Top Who We Are | Q&A | Rates In Michigan | Rates Around the Midwest
News and Information | Get Involved | Home
|
